The long-term complications suffered by patients with PA affects their prognosis (3). Certainly, they increase morbidity and mortality rates outside of the influence of acute decompensation episodes. Pancytopenia has generally been described as occurring during periods of acute decompensation, but patients can also experience anemia, neutropenia or thrombocytopenia outside of these times (2).
Given the small number of patients with PA, the actual prevalence of hematological complications is unknown. A recent meta-analysis determined anemia to be more common than cardiomyopathy or lesions in the basal ganglia (3). In another study of the long-term complications of organic acidemia and urea cycle disorders (as recorded in the European Registry of Organic Acidemia and Urea Cycle Disorders), the not prevalence of anemia among patients with PA was determined to be 22%, while figures for leucopenia and thrombocytopenia reached 18% (5). The reason for these hematological problems may lie in the toxicity of accumulating metabolites such as 3-hydroxy propionic acid, methyl citrate or tiglyl glycine, a lack of certain nutrients (5), or mitochondrial dysfunction (3). The pancytopenia seen during decompensation episodes is generally reversible (6), (7), (2), supporting the idea that accumulating toxic metabolites are to blame. However, why hematological problems should occur during times of metabolic stability remains unclear.
The blood is a tissue with a high regeneration rate. The need for nutrients - especially amino acids - is therefore high compared to other tissues, leaving the hematopoietic tissue sensitive to malnutrition (8). Certainly, anemia associated with protein-energy malnutrition is relatively common in children and elderly people in general (9). The constant production of blood cells from hematopoietic stem cells (HCS) is also influenced by the latter’s microenvironment, a complex biological niche (10). In recent years, interest has grown in understanding the influence of diet on the physiology and viability of HCS. Several studies, particularly those investigating the pre-transplant conditioning of the bone marrow, have shown the influence exerted by dietary branched-chain amino acids and cysteine (Cys) on the function of HSC and their microenvironment. Indeed, Val and Cys have been reported indispensable for the maintenance of HSC (11). In vitro, neither human nor rat HSC can proliferate in media without these amino acids, and rats fed a Val-restricted diet show a reduced HSC count within a week (11). In another study that examined the effect of branched-chain amino acid balance on HSC viability, restricting the Val intake by 10% led to a significant fall in HSC numbers. The same 10% restriction in Val in the presence of increased Ile and Leu led to the complete blockage of HSC proliferation (12), although it is difficult to explain why.
The above evidence suggests that a low intake of Val compared to a normal/high intake of Leu and Ile can have a negative effect on the bone marrow. Certainly, among the present patients, the association between reduced plasma Val and Ile and high plasma ferritin highlights a relationship between the persistence and severity of anemia and diet.
The diet of patients with AP is restricted in Val and Ile and provides normal or high amounts of Leu, but during emergency treatment the intake of PHBV needs to be reduced or even suspended altogether (2). Such periods of instability can be common during the first years of life, resulting in considerable fluctuations in the PHBV intake. According to recommendations made by the latter authors, Ile supplements can be given to prevent acrodermatitis dysmetabolica associated with low Ile plasma levels(2) and all the patients included in the study received Ile supplements in order to avoid the dermatological complications. This might lead to a situation of very low intake of Val compared to a higher intake of Ile and a normal Leu. With the exception of a single old study in animal models (13), the literature contains little information on the toxicity of Val deficiency.
Mitochondrial dysfunction has also been proposed to underlie the hematological complications seen in PA (3). This dysfunction might be caused by the toxicity of 3-hydroxy propionic acid and methyl citrate (14), (15), (16), (17) (18), an increase in oxidative stress, and a reduction in antioxidant capacity (19) (20), (21) (22) (23) (24). Met is involved in antioxidant defenses via the synthesis of glutathione from Cys in the liver and and it was reported that HSC proliferation was also dependent on Cys as well as Val (11). It also participates in the synthesis of S-adenosyl-L-methionine (SAM) via transmethylation reactions. Recent studies have revealed the role of SAM in the protection of cells from oxidative stress induced by different toxins and free radicals (25). In the present patients, low plasma Met was also associated with high plasma ferritin revealing the need for transfusions, pointing to a likely deficiency in bone marrow antioxidant defenses.
The present results support the idea that anemia during metabolically stable periods in patients with AP has a nutritional component. The need for transfusion appeared when the PHVB intake fell below 10 g/day. The high ferritin levels resulting from repeated blood transfusions are associated with reduced plasma Val, Ile and Met. However, the toxicity of 3-hydroxy propionic acid and methyl citrate in the bone marrow, while normally thought to be associated with acute decompensation, should not yet be ruled out as a cause of chronic severe anemia. The present results also show high urine methyl citrate and plasma Gly to be associated with thrombocytopenia.
Imbalances between branched-chain amino acids have been reported by other authors to have undesirable metabolic effects in patients with PA and MMA (26). Also, excess Leu was found to reduce plasma Val and Ile by interfering with the LAT1 transport of amino acids (27). In addition, animals fed high doses of Leu show low central nervous system concentrations of tryptophan (Trp), Val, Ile, Met and low brain alanine (Ala), which might affect the synthesis of neurotransmitters (28). Other authors have reported the importance of branched-chain amino acid equilibrium in body growth and cellular immunity in animal models (29), (30).
The reason why HSC are so sensitive to a reduced Val intake and to disequilibrium between branched-chain amino acids has not been explored. However, it may involve Val's role as a structural unit of proteins, or some relationship with cell signaling.
The present work is the first to provide positive evidence of a nutritional component underlying the hematological complications of AP during stable metabolic periods, adding weight to other authors' suspicions (26). For patients with PA, ways to maximize protein intake while reducing the intake of Leu need to be found.
The small number of patients examined is a limitation of the present work. Confirmatory studies involving international registries should be performed.