3.1 Thermogravimetric analysis
The nitridation behavior of the DWSP before and after doping with Ni was studied through thermogravimetric analysis in the nitrogen atmosphere, the test temperature rose from 25℃ to 1460℃ at a heating rate of 10℃/min, as shown in Fig. 1. It could be found that the variation trend of both was similar, but the mass gain of the DWSP doped with Ni was obviously higher than that of the direct nitridation of the DWSP. In addition, both TG curves had obvious inflection points, when the test temperature exceeded the temperature of the inflection point, the mass began to increase significantly. By comparison, the temperature corresponding to the inflection point of the mass gain curve of the DWSP doped with Ni was 1325℃, which was lower than the temperature (1408℃) corresponding to the inflection point of the TG curve without Ni. These results indicate that Ni decreased the temperature at which the DWSP began to gain significant weight.
3.2 Nitridation of the DWSP without Ni additives
Figure 2a shows the XRD patterns of the DWSP after nitridation at different temperatures for 2 h. At 1300℃, it was clear that only Si peak was detected, indicating the DWSP had not been nitrided at this temperature evidently. On increasing the temperature to 1350℃, Si3N4 and tiny Si2N2O peaks were detected, but unreacted Si peaks maintained a high intensity, indicating the nitridation extent of the DWSP was still low. With increasing the temperature to 1400℃, the intensity of Si3N4 peaks increased evidently, which indicates that the DWSP without Ni additives could effectively form Si3N4 only when the temperature reached 1400℃. Upon further increasing the temperature to 1450℃, Si peak disappeared, indicating the DWSP could be completely nitrided at 1450℃ for 2 h. When the temperature was improved to 1500℃, the phase compositions of the sample had no obvious changes.
Corresponding relative content of the phase compositions of the samples were calculated and shown in Fig. 2b. There was no Si3N4 formed at 1300℃, and only 56.1 wt.% of Si3N4 was formed at 1350℃. When improving the temperature from 1350℃ to 1400℃, the content of Si3N4 increased to 80.5% whereas the content of unreacted Si decreased to 9.2 wt.%. When the nitridation temperature reached to 1450℃, residual Si in the nitridation product disappeared, indicating only when the nitridation temperature reached at least 1450℃, the DWSP without additives could be completely nitrided. Finally, when the temperature was increased to 1500℃, there were no obvious changes.
3.3 Nitridation of the DWSP with different contents of Ni additives
Figure 3a illustrates the XRD patterns of the DWSP doped with various contents Ni additives after nitridation at 1300℃ for 2 h. Obviously, only Si peak was detected in the samples without Ni additives. When the sample only containing 0.5 wt.% Ni, the phases composition changed evidently, Si3N4 and a small amount of Si2N2O were identified. With increasing the Ni additives to 1.5 wt.%, Si peak decreased until it disappeared gradually, indicating the DWSP had been completely nitrided. With the further increase of Ni content to 2.0 wt.%, the sample phases had no obvious changes.
Corresponding relative content of the phase compositions of the samples were shown in Fig. 3b. When the content of Ni additives increased from 0 wt.% to 0.5 wt.%, unreacted Si decreased from 100 wt.% to 12.4 wt.% at 1300℃. Meanwhile, α-Si3N4, β-Si3N4 and Si2N2O increased from 0 wt.% to 63.3 wt.%, 10.2 wt.% and 14.1 wt.%, respectively. On increasing Ni content to ≥ 1.5 wt.%, unreacted Si in the sample decreased to 0 wt.%. These results indicate the significant accelerating effect of Ni on the DWSP nitridation. Obviously, Si2N2O was detected in the samples whether it doped with Ni additives or not, there were two reasons: one was the high content of SiO2 in the DWSP (about 17 wt.%) (Jin et al., 2019) and the other was the trace oxygen contained in high-purity nitrogen.
Figure 4 presents typical SEM images and corresponding EDS results of the samples doped with 0–2.0 wt.% Ni after nitridation at 1300℃ for 2 h. As shown in Fig. 4a and b, the morphology of the product without Ni did not change significantly and kept the slice-liked structure of the DWSP. And only Si and O elements were detected in the product by EDS (Fig. 4c), indicating the DWSP had not been nitrided evidently, which was coincide with the previous XRD results shown in Fig. 3a. When the DWSP doped with 1.0wt.% Ni, the morphology of the product changed significantly, as shown in Fig. 4d and e. Many nanorods appeared in the product. Short nanorods with a diameter of about 25 nm were distributed on and around the surface of the granular products, and long nanorods with a diameter of about 60 nm were interspersed between the products. With increasing the Ni content from 1.0 wt.% to 2.0 wt.%, the quantity and of nanorods increased and most of the nanorods also increased to 60-200nm in diameter. It had been confirmed that (Huang et al., 2014; Longland and Moulson, 1978) these granular products were Si3N4 formed by gas-solid reaction and these nanorods were α-Si3N4 formed by gas phase reaction. This indicates that a large amount of gas was produced during nitridation. However, O elements had also been detected in the granular pruduct and nanorods except Si and N elements by EDS (Fig. 4f and i). It could be attributed to the surface of Si3N4 was oxidized into Si2N2O and the presence of SiO2 amorphous layer (Wang et al., 1998; Zhang et al., 2001).
3.4 Nitridation of the DWSP with 2.0 wt.% Ni additives at different temperature
Figure 5a illustrates the XRD patterns of the DWSP doped with 2.0 wt.% Ni additives after nitridation at different temperatures for 2 h. At 1200℃, unreacted Si peaks still maintained a high intensity, and weak Si3N4 and Si2N2O peaks appeared. On increasing the temperature to 1250℃, the intensity of Si3N4 and Si2N2O gradually increased, while Si peaks became significantly weaker. On further increasing the temperature to 1300℃, Si peaks disappeared, indicating the DWSP doped with 2.0 wt.% Ni additives was completely nitrided at this temperature. With increasing the temperature from 1300℃ to 1500℃, Si2N2O peak decreased whereas other peaks did not change evidently.
Corresponding relative content of the phase compositions of the samples were shown in Fig. 5b. At 1200℃, the content of unreacted Si reached 63.6 wt.%, indicating only a small portion of the DWSP was nitrided. On increasing the temperature to 1250℃, unreacted Si in the sample decreased to 3.3 wt.% whereas the content of Si3N4 increased from 27.1 wt.% to 72.2 wt.%. With increasing the temperature to 1300℃, there was no unreacted Si remained in the sample, indicating the complete nitridation of the DWSP. In contrast, the DWSP without Ni additives had not been nitrided yet at 1300°C, which indicates that Ni significantly promoted the nitridation of the DWSP and reduced the nitridation temperature. With the temperature further increased from 1300°C to 1500°C, the mass fraction of Si2N2O decreased from 19.6 wt.% to 5.9 wt.%, it could be attributed to the decomposition of Si2N2O (Jin et al., 2019a).
3.5 Analysis of Ni accelerated nitridation mechanism
The predominance area diagrams of Si-O-N-Ni system at 1523K and 1623K were conducted with FactSage 7.2, as shown in Fig. 6. In this work, the pressure in the furnace was 1.0×10− 1 MPa and the purity of nitrogen was 99.999%, so the nitrogen and oxygen pressure in the furnace was approximately 1×10− 1 MPa and 1×10− 6 MPa, respectively. The partial pressure of oxygen was much higher than that of the stable presence of Si3N4 and Si2N2O in the equilibrium state, so there would be no Si3N4 and Si2N2O formed, which was inconsistent with the previous nitridation results. Therefore, the trace oxygen in nitrogen participated in some reaction and was consumed.
Thermodynamic analysis proved that under the condition of P(N2) of 1×10− 1 MPa, different oxygen partial pressures correspond to different products. As the partial pressure of oxygen increased, Si3N4 was gradually oxidized into Si2N2O and eventually into SiO2. And it could be found that in the stable regions of Si2N2O and Si3N4, NixSiy phase coexisted stably with them, indicating the Ni-Si alloy phase was formed during the nitridation process. In addition, with increasing the temperature from 1523K to 1623K, the oxygen partial pressure required to obtain Si3N4 gradually increased when the nitrogen partial pressure was 1×10− 1 MPa.
The macroscopic morphology of the products at 1250℃ for 0 h nitridation were shown in Fig. 7a. Obviously, there was a layer of white-colored product above the sample doped with Ni additives, while the sample without Ni almost did not have this phenomenon. After separating and testing, it could be found that a large bulge peak appeared around 2θ = 21° in XRD pattern and the microstructure of the white-colored was fibrous and disordered, as shown in Fig. 7b and d, so it was mainly amorphous SiO2 nanowires caused by gas phase deposition. In addition, there were three Si diffraction peaks around 2θ = 28.4°, 47.4° and 56.1°, so the white-colored product also contained Si. This was due to the disproportionation reaction of partial SiO(g) at this temperature. These results indicate that Ni could promote the generation of SiO(g) at low temperature. But since O2 was more active than N2 at lower temperature, these SiO(g) was further oxidized by a small amount of O2 in N2 to form amorphous SiO2 above the product.
In order to observe the effect of Ni on SiO2 film more intuitively, the research ideas of surface physics and surface chemistry were introduced, and the equivalent substitution experiment was carried out by simulating a single DWSP particle with monocrystalline silicon block. The planar geometry of single-crystal silicon block was contributed to our study of the effect of Ni additives. As shown in Fig. 8a, when the single-crystal silicon block without Ni added on the surface was nitrided at 1250℃ for 0 h, there was no obvious change on the silicon block surface, only some nanoparticles existed, which were SiO2 nanoparticles detected by EDS (Fig. 8c). When the single-crystal silicon block with Ni added on the surface was nitrided at the same conditions, the surface crack occurred, as shown in Fig. 8b. And many fibrous products generated by gas reaction were found inside the crack, which were SiO2 nanofibers detected by EDS (Fig. 8d). In addition, a small amount of Ni element was also detected inside the fracture. These results indicate that Ni could promote the generation of SiO(g) at lower temperature and destruct the SiO2 film of the single-crystal silicon block surface.
Combined with the predominance area diagrams and the experimental results at 1250℃, the main reactions during nitriding are listed in Table 1. It could be seen that due to the high content of SiO2 on the surface of the DWSP as a protective layer, Si did not react with N2 during the initial nitridation stage, but reacted with SiO2 first as shown in Eq. (1). The SiO2 film cracked when the SiO partial pressure between Si and SiO2 film was high enough. Then internal Si exposed in N2 atmosphere and SiO(g) escaped. Due to the high partial pressure of oxygen at the initial stage and the high activity of O2, a small amount of O2 in N2 will first participate in the reaction and react with SiO(g) and internal Si to form SiO2, as shown in Eq. (2, 3). As the partial pressure of oxygen gradually decreased, Si2N2O began to form through the Eq. (4). Then the unreacted SiO(g) would react with N2 to form α-Si3N4 and O2 through the Eq. (5), as shown in the rod-liked products in Fig. 4. Meanwhile, the exposed internal Si would also react with N2 to form Si3N4 through the Eq. (6), as shown in the granular products in Fig. 4. It could be found that when SiO(g) reacted with N2 to form Si3N4, O2 also was generated, which increased the partial oxygen pressure, and part of Si3N4 would also be oxidized into Si2N2O, as shown in Eq. (7). In addition, O2 also reacted with unreacted Si and SiO(g) again. As the above process occurred repeatedly, a large number of rod-like products appeared.
Table 1
Related chemical reactions in the nitridation of DWSP.
Chemical reactions | ΔGθ/kJ·mol− 1 | equation |
Si(s) + SiO2(s) = 2SiO(g) | 714.21–0.360T | (1) |
2SiO(g) + O2(g) = 2SiO2(s) | -1631.87 + 0.554T | (2) |
Si(s) + O2(g) = SiO2(s) | -918.11 + 0.195T | (3) |
4Si(s) + 2N2(g) + O2(g) = 2Si2N2O(s) | -1827.38 + 0.557T | (4) |
6SiO(g) + 4N2(g) = 2Si3N4(s) + 3O2(g) | -854.69 + 1.153T | (5) |
3Si(s) + 2N2(g) = Si3N4(s) | -733.87 + 0.330T | (6) |
4Si3N4(s) + 3O2(g) = 6Si2N2O(s) + 2N2(g) | -2543.90 + 0.345T | (7) |
Figure 9. illustrates the standard Gibbs free energy for reactions (1)-(7). It can be found that the \({\Delta }\)Gθ of reaction (1) is all greater than 0 at the experimental temperature, while the \({\Delta }\)Gθ of reaction (5) also begins to be greater than 0 when the temperature reaches above about 700°. The \({\Delta }\)Gθ of other reactions are all less than 0 at the experimental temperature, indicating that all reactions can occur spontaneously except for reaction (1) and (5). It should be further noted that the \({\Delta }\)Gθ of reactions (1) and (5) are also related to the partial pressure of SiO and the partial pressure of O2, which can occur in actual nitridation ((Jin et al., 2019b)).
Figure 10. illustrates the typical microscopic morphology and corresponding EDS results of the DWSP containing 2.0 wt.% Ni after nitridation at 1300℃ for 2 h. As shown in Fig. 10a, b and c, nanoparticles (red dotted circle) existed on the top of some α-Si3N4 nanorods. EDS (Fig. 10d) analysis showed that the top nanoparticles contained Si and Ni elements. Combined with the predominance area diagrams of Si-O-N-Ni system, nanoparticles existed on the top were Ni-Si eutectic liquid alloy. Based on previous research (Wagner and Ellis, 1964), vapor-liquid-solid (VLS) mechanism was suitable to describe the growth of nanorods with nanoparticles on top. First, Ni promoted the generation of SiO(g) at lower temperature and destruct the SiO2 film on the DWSP surface and then formed liquid Ni-Si alloy. Pigeon et al. pointed out that liquid phases were significant contributors to the production of Si vapor (Pigeon et al., 1993). And since the solubility of gas in the liquid phase was higher than that in the solid state and the activation energy of liquid Si-N2 reaction was much lower than that required for the reaction of solid Si and N2 (Mukerji and Biswas, 1981), Si vapor and N2 began to dissolve in large quantities in the liquid alloy and react after the formation of liquid Ni-Si alloy. α-Si3N4 began to precipitate when the liquid phase alloy reached a certain supersaturation. As the reaction gas continued to dissolve into the liquid alloy, α-Si3N4 continued to grow to form the morphology as shown in Fig. 10.
A schematic of the growth of Si3N4 during the nitridation of the DWSP doped with Ni is shown in Fig. 11.