4.1 Aneuploidy of detected viable tumor cells
Intraoperative tumor metastasis occurred when large amounts of cancer cells were shed from primary tumor focus during surgical manipulation into the blood stream, becoming circulating tumor cells (CTC) and may target distant organs and develop metastatic tumors [16]. Reinfusion of viable tumor cells from intraoperative recovered blood poses potential risks of tumor dissemination and metastasis. However, due to scarce number of residual tumor cells from vast majority of leukocytes, capturing viable tumor cells from shed blood after IOCS-LDF treatment is difficult. Mi Sook Gwak reported using LDF to reduce the risk of reintroduction of hepatocellular carcinoma cells with PCR found that at high HCC cell load the filter cannot completely remove all the tumor cells[17]. Though PCR can detect CTCs gene copy numbers, accurate enumeration of CTCs by this strategy is not feasible [18]. Moreover, this method could not completely eliminate the interference from fragmented DNA in sampled blood. Other studies analyzed the remaining tumor cells using flow cytometry or immunohistopathologcial study in cell blocks or cultured cells found that no viable tumor cells could be detected or if there were any tumor cells found, the load was far less than the CTC numbers in the patients’ circulation [19,20]. However, restricted to the sensitivity and specificity of the above mentioned technologies, the isolation and capturing of viable tumor cells which were only several to several tens of number present in 1 ml of blood that contains billions of other cells were extremely difficult.
Currently, the majority of the methodology of detecting CTCs are restricted to the tumor cell density, size, and charge as well as biomarkers using antigen expression profiles and specific tumor antigen–antibody interactions to distinguish and isolate CTCs from other cells. However, a large quantity of primary CTCs are of smaller cell size (≤ WBCs) which makes it difficult to separate from WBC, and the rare CTCs are inevitability lost during filtration based cell size selection strategy [21]. Moreover, it is reported that positive EpCAM experssion rate ranges 37% - 42.3% of the various cancers with FDA-approved CellSearch system.The invasive tumor cells tend to loose their epithelial antigens by the epithelial to mesenchymal transition process, which results in loss of EpCAM on CTCs and made the capturing of CTCs more difficult [22]. On the other hand, capturing non-tumor derived epithelial cells originated from inflammation, trauma, surgery and benign epithelial hyperplasia may cause false positive results [23]. For renal cell carcinoma, the expression of EpCAM was absent and there is no widely acknowledged specific cell surface marker for RCC detection[24,25]. Therefore, a promising alternative approach of EpCAM-independent enrichment strategy has been introduced [26].
In this preliminary study, detecting aberrant chromosome is attempted as a way of capturing tumor cells in RCC patients. Aneuploidy is the abnormal alternation (either gain or loss) of chromosomes in a cell. It is estimated that 90% of solid tumors exhibit aneuploidy [21]. By integrating cellular and molecular approach of negative enrichment and immunostaining-fluorescence in situ hybridization (NE-iFISH), which is independent of cell size variation and free of anti-EpCAM perturbing, iFISH could simultaneously co-detecting biomarker expression qualitatively and quantitatively, as well as discovering chromosome aneuploidy [14, 27].
It is reported that unique molecular alterations such as loss of 3p and trisomy of chromosomes 7 is well characterized for clear cell and papillary RCC [28-31]. After negative enrichment, tumor cells are identified by iFISH. Aneuploidy of chromosome 8 and/or 7 were analyzed and tumor cells were differentiated (figure 3). In this way, we could separate CTCs from recovered blood in RCC with IVC thrombus patients. To our knowledge, this is the first time that aneuploidy of aberrent chormosome detection method was adopted with NE-iFISH to capture CTCs in the recovered blood of ccRCC patients with encouraging result.
It is interesting to note that CTCs recovered from intraoperative blood in ccRCC -IVC thrombus patients have the propensity of developing trisomy of chormosome 7 or 8. This chormosome karyotype was not reported before and deserve further exploration. It may be useful for future chromosome karyotype analysis and also for further study of the clinical significance in treatment efficacy of tumor recurrence, metastasis detection and prognosis.
4.2 IOCS-LDF and RCC metastasis
Radical nephrectomy and IVC tumor thrombectomy is widely acknowledged as the curative method for patients with RCC-IVC thrombus [32]. When the tumor thrombus extends to the right atrium, intraoperative establishment of extracorporeal circulation is required. Patients with Mayo-level III-IV often experienced life-threatening intraoperative major bleeding. As blood resource is limited, scheduled surgeries are always delayed. A recent meta-analysis has shown that the infusion of allogeneic blood during radical prostatectomy, radical nephrectomy and cystectomy lead to worsened prognosis for patients [33], and this may be related to transfusion-related immunomodulation [34]. The application of IOCS-LDF is an effective alternative for massive blood transfusion. A study concerning the IVC tumor thrombus extending to right atrium has shown that the use of cardiopulmonary bypass and cell-saver technique in borderline situations like combined oncologic and cardiovascular surgery without increasing the risk of hematogenous tumor dissemination. Postoperative cytological investigation showed that the tumor cells were only found on the internal surface of the heart-lung machine arterial filters. No distant metastasis was found in all surviving patients [35].
There were limited clinical study concerning the safety of returning shed blood to RCC - IVC thrombus patients. Moskowitz reported a Jehovah’s Witness patient with RCC-IVC thrombus extending into the right atrium underwent surgery received the return of 3 L of salvaged erythrocytes during surgery without immediate complication, but the patient’s long-term outcome was not reported [16]. A study including 10 patients underwent radical nephrectomy with IVC and atrial thrombi surgery was followed-up for 46 months. Unfortunately, the only use of IOCS in conjunction with cardiopulmonary bypass renders the conclusions difficult to ascertain, and comparisons between the usage of IOCS are confounded by disease severity and level of caval thrombus [36] .
Timothy D reported 67 renal cancer patients undergone partial nephrectomy using IOCS-LDF without increasing postoperative complications or tumor recurrence, and 2 years of follow-up showed no metastasis [37]. Another retrospective cohort study was performed to assess the impact of intra-operative cell salvage on outcomes in open nephrectomy with 16 patients using IOCS and 24 without, concluding that IOCS appears to be a safe way with low rates of tumor recurrence and complications [38]. A meta-analysis in 2019 systematically evaluated the safety and effectiveness of IOCS in urological procedures by comparing the rate of allogeneic blood transfusion and tumor recurrence, complications, and medical costs. For the 14 observational studies (4536 patients) that were finally included, compared with other blood protection methods, IOCS was considered to reduce the rate of allogeneic blood transfusions and reduce medical costs, without affecting the incidence of complications. The author concluded from 10 studies that tumor recurrence was found to be significantly less common or similar in IOCS group. Eight of the studies were performed on prostate surgery, and only one was followed up for more than 5 years [39]. For nephrectomy and cystectomy, tumor recurrence after IOCS needs to be further studied.
4.3 Leukocyte filter and tumor cell filtration
Leukocyte depletion filter (LDF) is a filtering device based on a membrane-like filter material to remove leukocytes from blood. Its mechanism for removing tumor cells is physical interception and charge adsorption based on cell size. Study from hepatocellular carcinoma cells has shown that once the cell number exceeds 1 × 105, LDF cannot effectively filter tumor cells [40]. Hanse compared 9 different LDF filters and found that the reduction rates of tumor cell lines is within the range of 4 - 5 log, but only 3 log of prepared cells from solid tumor could be filtered. It is estimated that up to 107 tumor cells were shed during oncologic surgery, therefore it is unsafe to return autologous blood after LDF filtration [41]. In many types of tumor surgery, the actual number of shed tumor cells ranges approximately 0.2-4000/ml [42]. Existing evidence suggested that only for malignancies of advanced stage or tumor rupture during surgery can there be possibilities of ineffective clearance of LDF. Kai Mei and colleague reported by applying mannitol-adenine-phosphate (MAP) solution, the tumor cell clearance rate was increased from 2-3 log to 4-5 log with modified-LDF (M-LDF). For blood mixed with HepG2 cell (106-107), 67% inoculated nude mice developed tumors with unfiltered blood, while no solid tumor appeared in inoculated nude mice after filtering with M-LDF [43]. Therefore, it is considered that M-LDF with MAP had higher filter efficiency, but further clinical evidence is warranted. In the current study, we demonstrated with aneuploidy method, all the tumor cells in 5 patients were completely removed after LDF treatment, and intraoperative IOCS-LDF usage could clear all tumor cells in RCC - IVC thrombus patients with high efficiency.
4.4 IOCS-LDF for RCC-IVC thrombus tumor cell removal
In this study, 5 RCC - IVC thrombus patients were enrolled and 20 blood samples taken at different sites and stages during surgery were studied. Samples of S1 is indicative of the circulating tumor cells; S2 indicated peri-thrombus tumor cells shedding into inferior vena cava during operation; S3 represents the tumor cell cleaning efficacy with IOCS; and S4 is the actual final filtering result after LDF. Tumor cell numbers from all S4 samples were zero after IOCS-LDF treatment. This demonstrated that IOCS-LDF is effective in removing tumor cells. To our surprise, the number of tumor cells in internal jugular vein from S1 is most abundant (3, 4, 10, 7 and 3, respectively), while the number from S2 decreased dramatically (0, 0, 2, 5 and 1). This might be explained by the solid texture of the IVC thrombus and its smooth surface which could extend itself way up to the atrium without being flushed away by blood flow in the inferior vena cava. This also indicate that intraoperative exploration of the tumor thrombus does not necessarily result in significant shedding of tumor cells which might lead to tumor dissemination. Our study also demonstrated that IOCS alone is not enough for tumor cell depletion as CTCs were still detected in 2/5 cases from S3. The IOCS-LDF is efficient in depleting tumor cells from recovered blood as the number of CTCs reduced to 0 in all S4 samples. Due to limited sample size, further research with enlarge sample size is needed to verify the clearance ability of IOCS-LDF on RCC-IVC thrombus cases. Considering cell size differences, the application of IOCS-LDF to other tumor types may not achieve the equivalent effect.
Moreover, we also found that there is no close correlation between the amount of blood loss and the number of CTCs from the current study, which was also stated by Ernil Hansen in their research [42]. The number of CTCs were more prominent in patients with more advanced tumor stage and higher WHO-ISUP grading as well as Mayo-level grading. In case 3 and 4, the Mayo-level grading were II and IV, and the WHO-ISUP grading were G3 and G2, respectively. In case 3, the number of CTCs were 10 (S1) and 3 (S2), and the size of the dissected tumor is 12 cm*10 cm*6 cm; wile for case 4, the number of CTCs were 7 (S1) and 5 (S2), with the size of the dissected tumor 5 cm*3 cm*2.5 cm. However, it is arbitrary to reach any definitive conclusion based on the limited sample size. Further research is warranted in verifying this finding.