The search of the databases yielded 25 relevant references which are closely related to defining the inclusion criteria and was included in this review. The retrieved articles describe studies conducted in Morocco (n = 11) [9–19], Algeria (n = 5) [20–24], and Tunisia (n = 9) [25–33]. Overall, 15 studies investigated both BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes [9, 10, 13, 16–19, 21–23, 25, 28, 30–33], four studies examined the entire coding regions of the BRCA1 gene [11, 20, 26, 27], and six studies in which the analysis was restricted to a few BRCA1 and/or BRCA2 exons [12, 14, 15, 24, 29].
Overall, we observed 76 distinct BRCA PVs (44 in BRCA1 and 32 in BRCA2). The identified variants are current in 196 BC and/or OC patients (129 BRCA1 carriers and 67 BRCA2 carriers). A total of 18 of the 76 (23.7%) PVs [10/44 (22.7%) in BRCA1, 8/32 (25%) in BRCA2] were reported for the first time and were considered to be novel PVs in the North African populations. Among them, four PVs were reported in Morocco (c.3453delT in BRCA1 [19], and c.3381delT, c.7110delA, c.7234_7235insG in BRCA2 [10], three in Algeria (deletion of exon2 in BRCA1 [21], c.2805delAand c.6450del in BRCA2 [22], and eleven in Tunisia (c.211dupA [25, 26], c.296_297delTG [33], c.2418dupA [32], c.3254delG [33], c.3364_3370dupACAGATT [33], c.3751dup [29], c.4067_4071delAAGAA in BRCA1 [33] and c.1313dupT [28], c.1976_1800delCTTAT [28], c.2095C > T [33], c.7654dupT [28] in BRCA2). The reported PVs in BRCA genes from North African studies are presented in Table 2.
Table 2
Pathogenic BRCA1 and BRCA2 variants identified in North African breast/ovarian cancer patients
| Exon | Mutation type | Protein consequence | Number of cases | Country | Cancer site | Familial Sporadic | References |
BRCA1 Pathogenic variants |
c.46_74del29 | 2 | FS | p.Asn16fs | 2 | Algeria | BC | 1 Familial 1 Sporadic | [20] |
c.66_67delAG | 2 | FS | p.Glu23fs | 2 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [16] |
c.68_69delAG | 2 | FS | p.Glu23fs | 4 | Morocco | 3 BC, 1 OC | Familial | [9] |
Del exon 2 | 2 | LGR | - | 2 | Algeria | 1 BOC, BC | Familial | [21],[22] |
c.83_84delTG | 3 | FS | p.Arg28fs | 2 | Algeria | BC | 1 Familial 1 Sporadic | [20],[21] |
c.116G > A | 3 | MS | p.Cys39Tyr | 1 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [18] |
c.181T > G | 5 | MS | p.Cys61Gly | 3 | Morocco, Algeria | BC | Familial | [8],[19] |
c.211dupA | 5 | FS | p.Arg71fs | 19 | Tunisia | 3 BC, 2 BOC | Familial | [25],[26], [28], [29],[32] |
c.212 + 2insG | 5 | Splicing | - | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [31] |
Del exon 8 | 8 | LGR | - | 1 | Algeria | BC | Familial | [21] |
c.2338C > T | 10 | NS | p.Gln780Ter | 2 | Tunisia | OC | 1 Familial 1 Sporadic | [33] |
c.798_799delTT | 11 | FS | p.Ser267LysfsX19 | 18 | Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia | BC | 16 Familial 2 Sporadic | [10],[11],[13], [16],[17],[18], [20],[21],[30], [31] |
c.1016dupA | 11 | FS | p.Val340LysfsX6 | 3 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [11],[16] |
c.1504_1508delTTAAA | 11 | FS | p.Leu502fs | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [28] |
c.1817delC | 11 | FS | p Pro606Leufs6 | 2 | Algeria | BC | 1 Familial 1 Sporadic | [20],[22] |
c.202 + 1G > A | 11 | FS | - | 1 | Algeria | BC | Familial | [20] |
c.296_297delTG | 11 | FS | p.V99fs*9 | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [33] |
c.2125_2126insA | 11 | FS | p.Phe709Tyrfs | 4 | Morocco, Algeria | BC | 3 Familials 1 Sporadic | [17],[18], [19], [23] |
c.2418dupA | 11 | MS | p.Ala807Serfs | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [32] |
c.2551delG | 11 | FS | p.Glu851fs | 2 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [25],[26] |
c.2745dupT | 11 | NS | p.Ser915fs | 1 | Algeria | BC | Sporadic | [20] |
c.2805delA | 11 | FS | p.Asp936Ilefs | 2 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [10],[12] |
c.3254delG | 11 | FS | p.Arg1085Asnfs2 | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [33] |
c.3279delC | 11 | FS | p.Tyr1094Ilefs | 6 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [10],[12],[16] |
c.3331_3334delCAAG | 11 | FS | p.Gln1111fs | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [31] |
c.3364_3370dupACAGATT | 11 | FS | Stop1115 | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [33] |
c.3453delT | 11 | FS | p.Asp1151Glufs | 1 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [19] |
c.3715delT | 11 | FS | p.Ser1239fs | 1 | Algeria | BC | Sporadic | [20] |
c.3751dup | 11 | FS | p.Thr1251fs | 1 | Tunisia | OC | Familial | [29] |
c.4041_4042delAG | 11 | FS | p.Gly1348fs | 4 | Tunisia | 1 BC, 2 BOC, 1MBC | Familial | [25],[26], [29], [33] |
c.4065_4068del | 11 | FS | p.Asn1355Lysfs10 | 1 | Algeria | BC | Familial | [22] |
c.4067_4071delAAGAA | 11 | FS | p.GLn1356Argfs8 | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [33] |
c.5095C > T | 14 | MS | p. Arg1699Trp | 2 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [11] |
c.4676- ? _4986 + ? Del/p. ? | 15 | ? | - | 2 | Algeria | 1 BOC,1 BC | Familial | [24] |
c.5030_5033delCTAA | 15 | NS | p.Thr1677Ilefs2 | 3 | Tunisia | 1 BOC,2 OC | Familial | [33] |
c.4823C > G | 16 | NS | p.Ser1608Ter | 1 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [16] |
c.4942A > T | 16 | NS | p.Lys1648X | 1 | Morocco | BC | Sporadic | [11] |
c.5062_5064delGTT | 17 | FS | p.Val1688del | 1 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [10] |
c.5117G > C | 18 | MS | p.Gly1706Ala | 1 | Algeria | BC | Familial | [23] |
c.5158C > T | 18 | MS | p.Arg1720Trp | 1 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [16] |
c.5266dupC | 20 | FS | p.Gln1756Profs | 11 | Tunisia | 9 BC, 2 BOC | Familial | [25],[26],[27], [28],[29],[31] |
c.5309G > T | 20 | MS | p.Gly1770Val | 10 | Morocco | 9BC,1 OC, | 8 Familial 2 Sporadic | [14],[18] |
c.5332 + 1G > A | 20 | Splicing | - | 2 | Algeria | 1 BC, 1 OC | Familial | [22],[24] |
c.5390C > A | 22 | NS | p.Ser1797Ter | 1 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [18] |
BRCA2 Pathogenic variants |
c.17_20delAAGA | 2 | FS | p.Lys6Argfs17 | 2 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [33] |
c.250C > T | 3 | NS | p.Gln84Ter | 1 | Algeria | BC | Familial | [33] |
c.289G > T | 3 | NS | p.Glu97Ter | 1 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [23] |
c.517_1G > A | Intron 6 | SA | - | 1 | Morocco | BC | Sporadic | [10] |
c.632_1G > A | 7 | Splicing | - | 2 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [33] |
c.1302_1305delAAGA | 10 | FS | p.Lys437fs | 1 | Morocco | OC | Familial | [16] |
c.1309del4 | 10 | FS | Stop459 | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [26] |
c.1310_1313delAAGA | 10 | FS | p.Lys437IlefsX22 | 26 | Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia | 25 BC, 1MBC | Familial | [15], [19], [21], [29], [33] |
c.1313dupT | 10 | FS | Stop451 | 2 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [28] |
c.1528G > T | 10 | NS | p.Glu510 | 1 | Algeria | BC | Familial | [22] |
c.1813dupA | 10 | FS | p. Ile605Asnfs11 | 1 | Algeria | BC | Familial | [24] |
c.1976_1800delCTTAT | 10 | FS | p.Ser599 | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [33] |
c.2095C > T | 10 | NS | p.Gln699Ter | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [33] |
c.5116_5119delAATA | 11 | FS | p.Arg2108Cys | 2 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [17], [18] |
c.3381delT | 11 | FS | p.Phe1127Leufs | 1 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [17] |
c.3847_3848delGT | 11 | FS | p.Val1283fs | 1 | Morocco | OC | Familial | [10] |
c.3860delA | 11 | FS | p.Asn1287fs | 1 | Morocco | BOC | familial | [16] |
c.5073dupA | 11 | FS | p.Trp1692Metfs | 2 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [9] |
c.5576_5579delTTAA | 11 | FS | p.I1859fs | 1 | Morocco | OC | familial | [16] |
c.5682insA | 11 | FS | - | 1 | Tunisia | BC | familial | [26] |
c.5722_5723delCT | 11 | FS | p.Leu1908Argfs2 | 1 | Algeria | BC | familial | [21] |
c.6450del | 11 | FS | p.Val2151Phefs17 | 1 | Algeria | BC | familial | [22] |
c.7110delA | 14 | FS | p.Lys2370Asnfs | 2 | Morocco | 1 OC, 1BC | familial | [10], [16] |
c.7234_7235insG | 14 | FS | p.Thr2412fs | 3 | Morocco | BC | Familial | [10], [19] |
c.7235_7236insG | 14 | FS | p.Lys2413fs | 1 | Morocco | OC | Familial | [16] |
c.7654dupA | 16 | FS | p.Ile2552Asnfs2 | 2 | Algeria | BC | Familial | [22], [24] |
c.7654dupT | 16 | FS | p.Ile2552fs | 2 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [28] |
c.8485C > T | 19 | NS | p.Gln2829 | 1 | Algeria | BC | familial | [24] |
Del exons 19–20 | 19/20 | LGR | - | 1 | Algeria | BC | familial | [22] |
c.8940delA | 22 | FS | p.Glu2981Lysfs7 | 1 | Algeria | BOC | Familial | [24] |
c.9097delA | 22 | FS | p.Thr3033Leufs | 1 | Tunisia | BC | Familial | [33] |
c.9364G > A | 25 | MS | p.Ala3122Thr | 1 | Algeria | BC | familial | [23] |
FS: frameshift mutation, LGR: Large genomic rearrangement, MS: missense mutation, BC: breast cancer, OC: ovarian cancer, BOC: breast and ovarian cancer, NS: Nonsense mutation |
Among those identified as unlikely to be of North African origin including the BRCA1 c.68_69del and BRCA1 c.5266dupC Jewish founder variants, as well as PVs that have been reported as founder variants in European populations (ex: BRCA1 c.181T > G in Poland). Furthermore, other PVs have been described worldwide and represented as common PVs in several populations (ex: BRCA1 c.1016dupA in Italy, Germany, Scandinavian countries and French-Canadians, BRCA1 c.2125_2126insA in French-Canadians, BRCA1 c.2338C > T and BRCA2 c.1813dupA in Germany, BRCA1 c.5030_5033delCTAA in France, BRCA2 c.3860delA in Austrian population, and BRCA2 c.3847_3848delGT in Denmark).
The most well characterized five PVs are four in BRCA1 gene including c.211dupA (19/129, 14.7%) [25, 26, 28, 29, 32], c.798_799detTT (18/129, 14%) [10, 11, 13, 16–18, 21, 26, 27, 30], c.5266dup (11/129, 8.5%) [25–29, 31], c.5309G > T (10/129, 7.8%) [14, 18], c.3279delC (6/129, 4.7%) [10, 12, 16] and one in BRCA2 including c.1310_1313detAAGA (26/67, 38.9%) [15, 19, 21, 29, 33]. The BRCA1 c.798_799delTT was identified in 18 North African patients, accounting for 14% (18/129) of total identified BRCA1 PVs [10, 11, 13, 16–18, 20, 21, 26, 27, 30]. Microsatellite markers in and flanking the BRCA1 locus showed a common haplotype in Algerian and Tunisian c.798_799delTT carriers, suggesting the first non-Jewish founder variant to be described in Northern Africa [20]. The c.798_799delTT variant, located in exon 11, is a frame-shift variant including two small deletions, two bases (TT) deletion, that cause truncated protein signal at codon 285.
The other frequent recurrent PVs c.211dupA [25, 26, 28, 29, 32] and c.5266dupC [25–29, 31] were found in 55.6% (30/54) of BRCA1-related hereditary breast and ovarian cancer (HBOC) in Tunisian families but neither in Algerian nor in Moroccan families with BC and/or OC. The c.211dupA variant seems to be the most frequent BRCA PVs in Tunisia, accounting for 35.2% (19/54) of all identified BRCA1 PVs [25, 26, 28, 29, 32]. It seems to be specific to Tunisia since it has never been previously described in any other population. Haplotype analysis supported the founder effect of c.211dupA in Tunisia and showed its recent origin. The frameshift variant c.211dupA results in a premature protein termination at codon 79 at the level of the splicing donor site of exon 5.
The c.5266dupC variant in BRCA1 exon 20 was detected in most Tunisian series, accounting for 20.4% (11/54) of all BRCA1 PVs [25, 26, 27, 28, 31]. Haplotype analysis indicates the likelihood of a single founder origin both in Europe and in North America for the c.5266dupC variant [34]. Haplotype analysis may be useful in establishing whether or not it has a common founder origin for all BRCA1 c.5266dupC variant in Tunisia. The BRCA1 c. 5266dupC variant results in a frameshift, which alters the protein's amino acid sequence beginning at position 1756 and leads to a premature termination codon 73 amino acids downstream.
The BRCA1 c.5309G > T variant was identified in ten patients of which 9 BC and 1 OC, two of the BC patients were sporadic cases [14, 18]. A haplotype linked to c.5309G > T, constructed from five microsatellite markers and spanning 1.54 Mb, was defined in one family. The alleles found in the other families are consistent with this haplotype, supporting the founder effect of c.5309G > T in Morocco [14, 35, 36]. This mutation was first reported in Spain in two families of Moroccan origin and was classified as probably pathogenic on the basis of a combination of functional and structural analyses [18]. The c.5309G > T variant in BRCA1 is located in the functionally important BRCA1 carboxyl-terminal domain, a domain known to harbor missense substitutions associated with increased risk of BC and/or OC. The c.5309G > T variant should be treated as a disease-causing variant despite a lack of evolutionary conservation at glycine at position 1770 [35].
The BRCA1 c.3279delC variant mutation is a recurring PV in the Moroccan population. Its accounts for 12.2% (6/49) of the BRCA1 mutations [10, 12, 16], suggesting a possible founder effect. The c.3279delC variant in exon 9 is a frame shift variant including one small deletion, one base (C) deletion. The deletion causes a frame-shift which changes a tyrosine to isoleucine at codon 1094 and creates a premature stop codon at position 15 of the new reading frame.
The BRCA2 c.1310_1313delAAGA frameshift PV is considered as a North African recurrent mutation since it has been identified in Moroccan [15, 19], Algerian [21], and Tunisian [29] BC patients. Interestingly, geographical clustering in the North-Eastern area of Morocco is evident for the c.1310_1313delAAGA mutation, suggesting a founder effect [15]. c.1310_1313delAAGA incidence rate is higher and accounts for 50% (17/34) of all BRCA2 PVs in North-East of Morocco [15]. This sequence change deletes four nucleotides from exon 10 of the BRCA2 mRNA, causing a frameshift after codon 437 and the creation of a premature translational stop signal 22 amino acid residues.