In present study, a novel adjuvant LCpG was developed by covalent conjugation of CpG to gold nanoparticles conjugated with mannose and lipids. The designed adjuvant could be rapidly transported to and retained longer in the lymphoid nodes, and promoted DC maturation. In melanoma model, LCpG controlled both primary melanoma and its metastasis, and established long-term memory dependent upon tumor specific Tc1 response. In tumor microenvironments, antigen-specific Tc1 induced by the LCpG skewed tumor associated macrophages to M1 phenotype, inhibited Treg differentiation and induced proinflammatory cytokines production in a CTL-derived IFN-γ-dependent manner (Fig. 7).
T cell immunity is the key mechanism of antitumor effect. CTLs recognize MHC I and peptide complex expressed on tumor cells, and lyse them directly. Thus, immunotherapy aims to promote CTL response. However, most of the immunotherapies result in low response rate, due to the formation of “cold tumors”. The main mechanisms involved in the formation of “cold tumors” include poor for providing costimulatory signals for T cell priming by APCs and deficit of T cell homing into the tumor bed [17]. DC, the most effective APC, plays a central role in activating T cells by providing TCR ligand, costimulatory molecules and cytokines. During T cell priming, DC need to be activated and become matured first. m6A is the most prevalent modification of eukaryotic RNA involved in various cellular responses by regulating mRNA biology [18]. RNA m6A modification is essential for DC activation by promoting the expression of co-stimulatory molecules CD40, CD80 and cytokine IL-12 [19]. LCpG dramatically promoted RNA m6A of DC, in comparison to uncongugated CpG. The advantages of LCpG on activating DC can be translated in vivo. In tumor-bearing mice, LCpG promotes DC activation by upregulated MHC II and B7 molecules expression on its surface. B7, the ligand of CD28, is the most important costimulatory molecules for T cell priming [20]. All these results demonstrate that LCpG is a promising adjuvant to activate T cell response by promoting DC activation.
CD8+ T cells can be activated in two different ways to become cytotoxic effector cells. The one is mediated by the help from Th cells, and another is mediated directly by DC which has high intrinsic co-stimulatory activity [21, 22]. The simpler manner of CTL activation is priming by activated dendritic cells directly. Therefore, any adjuvants which can greatly upregulate co-stimulatory on DC, have the potential to primed CTL directly. Although Th cells were activated by LCpG, depletion of CD4+ T cells didn’t reduce the therapeutic effects provided by CTL, suggested that LCpG could stimulate CTL response directly by matured DC. Following the T cell priming, cytokines drive the differentiation of effector T subtypes. IL-12 has been found to be essential for Tc1 differentiation [23], and LCpG treatment greatly increased the expression of IL-12, which was consistent with the augment of Tc1 in vivo. Thus, LCpG can activate Tc1 irrespective of Th activation, demonstrating its broad potential for cancer immunotherapy.
Although tumor-infiltrating CTLs can recognize and destroy tumor cells directly, most of CTLs infiltrating in tumor are dysfunctional and impaired in their ability to secret proinflammantory cytokines such as IFNγ and TNFα [24, 25]. In present work, LCpG included vaccine greatly increased CTLs infiltration in tumor, and enhanced their ability to produce both IFNγ and TNFα in TME. IFNγ is a key effector molecule with pleiotropic effects in TME during anti-tumor immunity [26, 27]. It stimulates tumor cells to upregulate peptide-MHC I complex, the ligand for TCR, and thus enhances the immunogenicity of cancer [28]. It also triggers the production of chemokines, such as CXCL9, CXCL10 and CXCL11, to promote the recruitment of effector immune cells to the tumor sites [29, 30]. Our data reveled that neutralization of IFNγ dramatically decreased CTL trafficking to tumor, and reduced the totally therapeutic benefits from LCpG treatment. The antitumor effects of CTL adoptive transferring also abrogated after anti-IFNγ treatment, suggesting the essential role of IFNγ during CTL recruitment and anti-tumor immunity. IFNγ is also known to be one of the key inducers of M1 polarization [31]. M1 macrophages expressed high level of B7 molecules, such as CD80 and CD86 [32], and many recent works have emphasized the positive impact of M1 TAMs on survival of cancer patients [33, 34]. Consistently, LCpG treatment promoted M1 polarization in tumor sites dependent upon CTL-derived IFNγ. Although, LCpG treatment increased Th1 in tumor bed, the most amounts of IFNγ in TME were produced by CTL instead of Th1, as the lack of peptide-MHCII complex, the ligand of Th cell, in tumor beds.
Tregs can contribute to tumor immune evasion by suppressing CTL function [35]. Foxp3, a forkhead/winged helix transcription factor, which is crucial for the development of Tregs, is the most reliable marker for Tregs [36]. It is reported that TNFα has divergent effects on regulatory T cells [37]. LCpG treatment promoted TNFα production in TME, and the most amounts of TNFα were secreted by infiltrating CTL. The increasing of TNFα in TME was correlated with the decreasing of infiltrating Treg populations. Ex vivo study confirmed the essential role of TNFα in inhibiting Treg differentiation, which is consistent with the former study that TNFα could inhibit FoxP3 transcription [38, 39]. Neutralization of TNFα didn’t reduce the therapeutic benefits from LCpG treatment, suggested that inhibiting Treg was not essential for the vaccine treatment.
It has been reported that tumor infiltrating CTLs have been associated with favorable clinical outcomes in a variety of cancers. However, these infiltrating CTLs may be actively restrained by inhibitory molecules expressed on their surface, such as PD-1 [40]. Blocking PD-1 signaling pathway has been tested in multiple cancer [41]. However, despite the success of monotherapies of blocking PD-1 in some cancers, most patients do not have durable clinical benefit. A major reason for the poor responding to PD-1 blocking therapy is the lack of CTL infiltration in the tumors. Our data demonstrated that melanoma-bearing mice treated with PBS + OVA had very low infiltration of CD8+T cells in TME. The relative low CTL infiltration may be caused by the lack of adjuvant to activate DC, revealed by low expression level of costimulatory B7 molecules and IL-12 after PBS + OVA treatment. This kind of “cold tumor” did not respond to PD-1 blockade treatment effectively. On the contrary, LCpG included vaccine greatly enhanced CD8+T cells accumulation in TME, which provided the targets for PD-1 blockade therapy, and thus combining LCpG included vaccine and anti-PD-1 therapy resulted in a synergistic effect in controlling tumor growth. Reduction of the benefits by CD8+ T cells depletion confirms that CTL is the target for PD-1 blockade strategies. Taken together, we demonstrated that LCpG inclusion in vaccine formulations activated Tc1 responses in vivo and regulating TME in a TCL-derived IFNγ-dependent manner. Further studies are required to fully understand superior activity of LCpG in preclinical models.