Effect of irradiation on physicochemical parameters in textile wastewater
The changes of physicochemical parameters for raw/unirradiated and irradiated wastewater are shown in Table 1. The main features of this textile wastewater were high pH, EC, TDS and TSS values with poor DO value. Similar values were also reported by Parvin et al. (2015) and comparatively lower values of pH, EC, TDS and TSS were found by Bhuiyan et al. (2015). The two-way ANOVA test (α = 0.05, p < 0.017) also revealed that the physicochemical parameters (pH, Turbidity, EC, TDS and TSS) were significantly reduced (Fcal > Fcritic = 3.12 > 2.6; df = 54; p = 0.002) at a 95% confidence level (Table 2), which is consistent with the Pearson’s correlation analysis (Table 3). The Pearson’s correlation analysis showed that pH has strong positive correlation with turbidity (r = 0.984, p = 0.002), EC (r = 0.0.992, p = 0.001), TDS (r = 0.990, p = 0.001), TSS (r = 0.985, p = 0.002), BOD (r = 0.997, p = 0.000), COD (r = 0.997, p = 0.002) and nitrate (r = 0.984, p = 0.002), while negative correlation was observed with DO (r = -0.996, p < 0.001), nitrogen (r = -0.971, p = 0.006) and ammonium (r = -0.992, p = 0.001). Therefore, it has been suggested that when pH values were reduced, at the same time turbidity, EC, TDS, TSS, BOD, COD and NO3 also reduced with the increasing of irradiation doses. Reversely, when pH values in wastewater were reduced, the values for DO, nitrogen (total) and ammonium were increased.
This study revealed that the pH values in the textile wastewater were gradually decreased with the rise of the irradiation doses from 3 to 10 KGy. At an irradiation dose of 10 KGy, the pH value in wastewater was found to be 8.19, which was enough for reuse as irrigation water since it satisfied the standard range of irrigation water (DoE 1997). It could happen because the application of gamma radiation oxidizes the more significant aromatic compounds that exist in the wastewater and generates mono and dicarboxylic acids or carbonic acid. Eventually, that forms carbon dioxide by further oxidation and lowers the pH value of the wastewater (Paul et al. 2011; Parvin et al. 2015; Bhuiyan et al. 2015).
The turbidity values for the textile wastewater samples were observed to reduce from 167.22-116.68 FTU. But the decreasing amount was almost similar for the doses of 8 KGy (118.56 FTU) and 10 kGy (116.68 FTU), having no such visible or analytical changes of turbidity within these doses (Table 1). The reduction in turbidity is, in fact, for the decrease in suspended particulate matter. Still, the practical logic is the destruction of larger organic dye molecules and the production of more minor colorless organic species by applying gamma radiation (Bagyo et al. 1997; Soutsas et al. 2010). The dissolved oxygen (DO) of the unirradiated wastewater was found only 0.3 mg/L (Table 1). Nevertheless, after gamma irradiation, it had increased to the standard value of 4.5-8 ppm for irrigation water (DoE 1997). The DO value gradually increased from unirradiated to irradiated textile wastewater but at a slower rate at the end. It might have occurred because of the demolition of larger molecules, the decrease in turbidity (Table 1) of the wastewater samples, along with the existence of radiolysis products of water (O2, H2O2, etc.) due to gamma irradiation (Miyata 1993).
At 10 KGy radiation dose, the EC value became 1690 µS/cm, which was comparatively lesser than the EC value found in raw wastewater (4010 µS/cm) but not close to the standard value (1200 µS/cm) for irrigation water (DoE 1997). However, higher radiation doses were required to reduce the EC value because of ionized constitutes in the wastewater. EC has an approximate correlation with TDS (Rouse 1979), which was consistent with our Pearson’s correlation data between EC and TDS (Table 3) having a strong positive correlation (r = 0.992, p < 0.005, α = 0.01). This study has been suggested that with the increment of irradiation dose, both EC and TDS values reduced significantly. A similar reduction tendency was also found for TDS (Table 1), which was 1540 mg/L at 10 KGy, lower than the recommended value of 2100 mg/L for irrigation quality of the water (DoE 1997). The suspended solids content of the wastewater readily lowered after the gamma-ray irradiation (Table 1). The TSS value was 486 mg/L for unirradiated wastewater and 217 mg/L for 10 KGy radiation dose, almost near to the standard TSS value (200 mg/L) for irrigation water as per DoE (1997). There are two probable causes of TDS and TSS reduction; the first is the deterioration of suspended dye molecules persuaded through the reaction with oxidative agents from hydrolysis of water (Getoff 1996; Somasiri et al. 2006). The second cause is the destruction of bigger organic molecules into tinier ones by radiation (Nickelsen et al. 1992).
Table 1 Change of Physicochemical parameters of the irradiated and unirradiated samples of textile wastewater.
Parameters
|
Unit
|
Raw / Unirradiated wastewater
|
Standard for irrigation water (DoE 1997)
|
Wastewater irradiated at different doses
|
This Study
|
Bhuiyan et al. (2015)
|
Parvin et al. (2015)
|
3 KGy
|
5 KGy
|
8 KGy
|
10 KGy
|
pH
|
-
|
10.48
|
8.3
|
10.33
|
6.0-9.0
|
9.72
|
9.18
|
8.64
|
8.19
|
Turbidity
|
FTU
|
167.22
|
-
|
161.65
|
-
|
153.83
|
139.29
|
118.56
|
116.68
|
EC
|
µS/cm
|
4010
|
2000
|
4140
|
1200
|
3640
|
2980
|
2160
|
1690
|
TDS
|
mg/L
|
3346
|
1050
|
3410
|
2100
|
2752
|
2460
|
1725
|
1540
|
TSS
|
mg/L
|
486
|
310
|
440
|
200
|
362
|
294
|
245
|
217
|
DO
|
mg/L
|
0.3
|
-
|
0.5
|
4.5-8.0
|
2.4
|
3.8
|
4.9
|
5.7
|
In the case of biological oxygen demand (BOD5) and chemical oxygen demand (COD), a notable reduction in BOD5 and COD values of the wastewater is observed with increasing radiation doses (Fig. 1). The recommended standard limit of BOD5 and COD for irrigation water is 100 mg/L and 400 mg/L, respectively set by DoE (1997) which were duly achieved for the wastewater irradiated at 8-10 KGy in this study. The present study also revealed that at the highest radiation dose of 10 KGy, 59.0% and 71.6% of BOD5 and COD removal were obtained. A strong positive correlation (r = 0.992, p < 0.005, α = 0.01) between BOD5 and COD was observed (Table 3). It could happen because the reason that the ˙OH radicals are produced by the radiolysis of wastewater reacting with suspended solid materials and degrade the organic contaminants (Selambakkannu et al. 2011). As a result, the degradation of these organic pollutants also reduces the bulk of biodegradable matters in wastewater, which results in the lowering of BOD5 and COD values (Bhuiyan et al. 2015). The decline in COD values of the wastewater samples after radiation treatment could increase the biodegradability index (BOD5/COD) ratio, which is evident from Fig. 1. However, the BOD5/COD ratio value elevated to 0.43 from 0.3 after irradiation. Also, 32.3 % to 44.4 % biodegradability of the wastewater samples increased after irradiation at 8-10 KGy (Fig. 1). For effective biological degradation of the wastewater biodegradability index (BOD5/COD) ratio value should be a minimum of 0.4 or higher (Symons et al. 1960; Al-Momani et al. 2002). In the present study, wastewater samples obtained biodegradability at 8-10 KGy radiation doses because at these doses BOD5/COD ratio was 0.4-0.43 (Fig. 1).
Table 2 Two ways ANOVA for effect of radiation dose on changes of different physicochemical parameters.
Source of Variation
|
SS
|
df
|
MS
|
F
|
P-value
|
F crit
|
Among variables
|
53742748
|
10
|
5374275
|
42.52468
|
3.68E-18
|
2.077248
|
Among doses
|
1577631
|
4
|
394407.7
|
3.120805
|
0.025176
|
2.605975
|
Error
|
5055205
|
40
|
126380.1
|
|
|
|
Total
|
60375585
|
54
|
|
|
|
|
Table 3 Pearson correlation matrix of different physicochemical parameters in wastewater changing irradiation doses.
|
pH
|
Turbidity
|
EC
|
TDS
|
TSS
|
DO
|
BOD
|
COD
|
Nitrogen
|
Ammonia
|
Nitrate
|
pH
|
1
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Turbidity
|
.984**
|
1
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EC
|
.992**
|
.991**
|
1
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TDS
|
.990**
|
.994**
|
.992**
|
1
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TSS
|
.985**
|
.966**
|
.959**
|
.968**
|
1
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
DO
|
-.996**
|
-.979**
|
-.979**
|
-.982**
|
-.996**
|
1
|
|
|
|
|
|
BOD
|
.997**
|
.985**
|
.997**
|
.987**
|
.970**
|
-.987**
|
1
|
|
|
|
|
COD
|
.997**
|
.991**
|
.991**
|
.996**
|
.987**
|
-.995**
|
.992**
|
1
|
|
|
|
Nitrogen
|
-.971**
|
-.970**
|
-.991**
|
-.973**
|
-.916*
|
.947*
|
-.986**
|
-.965**
|
1
|
|
|
Ammonium
|
-.992**
|
-.985**
|
-.978**
|
-.982**
|
-.996**
|
.998**
|
-.984**
|
-.994**
|
.944*
|
1
|
|
Nitrate
|
.978**
|
.959*
|
.987**
|
.973**
|
.927*
|
-.955*
|
.987**
|
.969**
|
-.993**
|
-.945*
|
1
|
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
Effect of irradiation doses on total nitrogen and ammonium in textile wastewater
This study revealed that the radiation treatment significantly improved the amount of total nitrogen (N) and ammonium (NH4+) contents in wastewater samples (Fig. 2). The unirradiated wastewater contained only 32.6 mg/L and 18.5 mg/L of total nitrogen and ammonium, but when the wastewater was irradiated at 10 KGy, total nitrogen and ammonia increased 63.4 mg/L and 34.6 mg/L, respectively. However, the total nitrogen content increased 68.7% at 8 KGy and 94.5% at 10 KGy. Again, 77.3% and 87.0% increase were observed for ammonium content in wastewater irradiated at 8 KGy and 10 KGy, respectively (Fig. 2). The finding for applying irradiation dose on total nitrogen and ammonium in wastewater was completely reverse to changing of pH value, which can be seen in the Pearson’s correlation data (Table 3). The Pearson’s correlation revealed a strong negative correlation between pH and total nitrogen (r = -0.971, p = 0.006, α = 0.01) and ammonium (r = -0.992, p < 0.005, α = 0.01). As a consequence of applying radiation, the stubborn portions of the azo dyes in wastewater have degraded efficiently, and thus nitrogen molecules appeared into the solution immediately after digestion (Nicklesen et al. 1992; Somasiri et al. 2006; Parvin et al. 2015). Besides, gamma radiation converted the existing azo dyes in wastewater into amides, which were then modified into ammonia by hydrolysis and then as ammonium ion, an important source of plant fertilizer (Bagyo et al. 1997).
Impact of irradiation doses on metals concentration in textile wastewater
This present study observed that the analyzed raw and irradiated wastewater samples carried a lower concentration of heavy metals (Table 4). The textile industry from where the wastewater samples were collected mainly consumes reactive and disperse dyes for dyeing. Shore (2002) reported that metal complex groups are not found in disperse dyes, and reactive dyes contain only 12-15 % of metal complex azo groups. Hence, it is expected to found a lower concentration of heavy metals in the studied wastewater samples. Heavy metals like Cr, Pb, Ni, and Cu are crucial because of their bio-accumulation solid capability, which could harm humans when introduced into the food cycle (Fisseha 1998; Itanna 2002). Among the heavy metals Pb, Cr, Zn, Co, Ni, Cu, Mn, and Hg showed higher values in the wastewater samples irradiated at 3, 5, 8, and 10 KGy doses than in unirradiated wastewater samples (Table 4). However, arsenic (As) and cadmium (Cd) were found less than the detection limit in elemental analysis. An increase in the metal contents in the irradiated wastewater may be due to the freeing of metals from trapped or chelating forms within the organic compounds that exist in the wastewater solution (Parvin et al. 2015). These obtained metal values were within the tolerable limits for using the wastewater as irrigation water (DoE 1997; Ayers and Westcot 1985; USEPA 2012). Only copper (Cu) and manganese (Mn) concentrations were higher, according to Ayers and Westcot (1985), but they were found well below the maximum allowable limit set by DoE (1997).
Table 4 Metal concentration (in mg/L) for raw and gamma irradiated textile wastewater.
Metal Name
|
Raw wastewater (0 KGy)
|
3 KGy
|
5 KGy
|
8 KGy
|
10 KGy
|
Standard for irrigation water a, b, c (mg/L)
|
a
|
b
|
c
|
Arsenic (As)
|
<0.0003
|
<0.0003
|
<0.0003
|
<0.0003
|
<0.0003
|
0.2
|
0.1
|
0.1
|
Cadmium (Cd)
|
<0.004
|
<0.004
|
<0.004
|
<0.004
|
<0.004
|
0.05
|
0.01
|
0.01
|
Calcium (Ca)
|
0.2348
|
0.3562
|
0.3498
|
0.4028
|
0.3853
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
Chromium (Cr)
|
0.0791
|
0.0827
|
0.0848
|
0.0965
|
0.0950
|
1
|
0.1
|
0.55
|
Cobalt (Co)
|
<0.004
|
0.0077
|
0.0080
|
0.0086
|
0.0089
|
-
|
0.05
|
0.05
|
Copper (Cu)
|
0.0544
|
0.0630
|
0.0661
|
0.0863
|
0.0825
|
3
|
0.2
|
0.017
|
Iron (Fe)
|
0.0099
|
0.0217
|
0.0190
|
0.0364
|
0.0383
|
2
|
5
|
0.5
|
Lead (Pb)
|
0.0317
|
0.0402
|
0.0446
|
0.0505
|
0.0527
|
0.1
|
5
|
0.065
|
Magnesium (Mg)
|
0.0957
|
0.1883
|
0.1627
|
0.2199
|
0.2577
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
Manganese (Mn)
|
0.1605
|
0.2484
|
0.2347
|
0.2775
|
0.2914
|
5
|
0.2
|
0.2
|
Mercury (Hg)
|
0.0011
|
0.0012
|
0.0013
|
0.0015
|
0.0015
|
0.01
|
-
|
-
|
Nickel (Ni)
|
<0.004
|
0.0093
|
0.0103
|
0.0127
|
0.0133
|
1
|
0.2
|
1.4
|
Potassium (K)
|
0.3752
|
0.7229
|
0.9294
|
1.1403
|
1.2546
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
Sodium (Na)
|
0.1938
|
0.6570
|
0.5860
|
0.8274
|
0.9483
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
Zinc (Zn)
|
0.0120
|
0.0172
|
0.0166
|
0.0185
|
0.0188
|
10
|
2
|
0.2
|
a DoE (1997)
b USEPA (2012)
c Ayers and Westcot (1985); Itanna (2002); Chiroma et al. (2014)
Also, a higher concentration of potassium (K), sodium (Na), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), and iron (Fe) were found in the irradiated wastewater than the unirradiated (Table 4), which could be helpful for plant growth as these are the vital micro and macronutrients for plants (Begum et al. 2011; Bhuiyan et al. 2015). In addition, heavy metals analysis of the soil used for plant cultivation was presented in Table 5. Almost all the heavy metal concentrations in the soil samples were within the maximum allowable limit (Ewers 1991; Itanna 2002; Chiroma et al. 2014; WHO 2006). Moreover, the other metals like Na, Mg, Ca, K, and Fe, essential for plant growth, were present in an expected concentration that made the soil suitable for the experiments.
Table 5 Metal concentration (mg/kg) in soil for plant cultivation.
Metal Name
|
Concentration (mg/kg)
|
Maximum Allowable limit a, b (mg/kg)
|
a
|
b
|
Arsenic (As)
|
1.33
|
20
|
8
|
Cadmium (Cd)
|
0.55
|
3
|
4
|
Chromium (Cr)
|
1.33
|
100
|
-
|
Calcium (Ca)
|
0.55
|
-
|
-
|
Cobalt (Co)
|
42.14
|
50
|
-
|
Copper (Cu)
|
168.78
|
100
|
-
|
Iron (Fe)
|
6.67
|
50000
|
-
|
Lead (Pb)
|
18.26
|
100
|
84
|
Magnesium (Mg)
|
34.46
|
-
|
-
|
Manganese (Mn)
|
26.68
|
2000
|
-
|
Mercury (Hg)
|
82.68
|
-
|
-
|
Nickel (Ni)
|
126.22
|
50
|
107
|
Potassium (K)
|
<0.003
|
-
|
-
|
Sodium (Na)
|
39.64
|
-
|
-
|
Zinc (Zn)
|
142.84
|
300
|
-
|
a Ewers (1991); Itanna (2002); Chiroma et al. (2014)
b WHO (2006)
Impacts of reused irradiated textile wastewater on Capsicum plants and fruits
In the present study, considerable changes were observed in plant morphologies for the Capsicum plants nourished by irradiated textile wastewater after 64 days of the experiment. Fig. 3 shows the variation in plant growth parameters such as average plant height (‘cm’ per week), the average number of leaves (per week), and root length up to 64 days (during harvesting) of Capsicum frutescens as a function of different radiation doses on textile wastewater including the unirradiated and control samples. The highest average plant height (4.07 cm) and most average number of leaves (16 nos.) were found for the plants irrigated by 8 kGy and 10 KGy irradiated wastewater. Also, these morphological values of Capsicum plants nourished by only freshwater (control sample) and unirradiated wastewater were lower than the plant treated by gamma-ray irradiated (3-10 kGy) wastewater (Fig. 3). Identical results were also observed in the case of root length for the Capsicum plants. As presented in Fig. 3, the maximum root length of 16.56 cm was found for the plants irrigated by 8 kGy, whereas 13.21 cm and 8.33 cm root lengths were found for the control sample and Capsicum plants treated with unirradiated textile wastewater, respectively. Notable growth in plant morphologies and root lengths were found for the plants irrigated by irradiated wastewater, perhaps because of the absorption of nutrients from the irradiated wastewater enriched with organic wastes and increased nutrients such as K, Na, Mg, and Zn (Begum et al. 2011; Bhuiyan et al. 2015).
Evident effects were also found on the dry mass, moisture content (%), fruit growing time, and the total number of fruits of Capsicum plants (Fig. 4) after implementing gamma-ray irradiated textile wastewater. The Capsicum fruits grew after 29 days on the plant nourished by wastewater radiated at 10 kGy. On the other hand, the plants fed with only water and raw wastewater, the fruits grew after 41 days and 59 days, respectively. Maximum 40 fruits and 3.02 g dry mass of these fruits were gained from the Capsicum plants treated by 8 kGy gamma-irradiated textile wastewater. The dry mass for the control sample was 2.25 g (total 25 fruits), and the plants treated with raw textile wastewater were 0.17 g (total two fruits only). According to Fig. 4, the other plants treated with 3, 5, and 10 kGy gamma-ray irradiated textile wastewater showed a better result than the plants treated with only raw textile wastewater. Contrariwise, the highest moisture content (93.2%) was found for the fruits collected from the plants treated with raw wastewater, and 92.62% moisture content was found for 8 KGy fruit samples, which showed comparatively better performance among the irradiated and control fruit samples. Gamma irradiated textile wastewater possessed a higher concentration of nitrogen and ammonia, which ultimately influenced the increase in dry mass and moisture content of the Capsicum fruits (Parvin et al. 2015; Bhuiyan et al. 2015).
Metals concentration in Capsicum fruits
The analysis of Capsicum fruit samples for heavy metals concentration and the macro and micronutrients was done and presented in Fig. 5a and 5b, respectively. The outcomes show that heavy metals concentration (Pb, Cr, Hg, Ni, Cu, and Zn) in Capsicum fruits decreased progressively as higher doses of treated wastewater were implemented (Fig. 5a). The outcome indicates a distinguished translocation of these metals from the soil to the plant reproductive organs. At the highest radiation dose of 10 KGy, Chromium (Cr) and lead (Pb) were found 0.04 mg/kg and 0.16 mg/kg for Capsicum fruit samples which were below the acceptable limit of 2.3 mg/kg and 0.3 mg/kg, respectively (Itanna 2002; Codex FAO/WHO 2001; Chiroma et al. 2014). Whereas Nickel (Ni) and Mercury (Hg) in Capsicum fruit samples were found below the detection limit in elemental analysis, and 0.925 mg/kg Ni was found only in the fruit samples irradiated by raw wastewater. Copper (Cu) content was reported up to 0.016 mg/kg in the fruit samples nourished by 10 kGy gamma-ray irradiated textile wastewater (Fig. 5a), which was exceedingly low compared to the highest permissible limit (73 mg/kg) of copper in vegetables (Itanna 2002; Codex FAO/WHO 2001; Chiroma et al. 2014). Zinc (Zn) concentration was 0.109 mg/kg in Capsicum fruit samples at 10 kGy, which was also insignificant against the maximum allowable limit of 100 mg/kg (Itanna 2002; Codex FAO/WHO 2001; Chiroma et al. 2014). Zn and Cu are essential nutrients for the plant that might be uptaken from the soil used for cultivation. The applied irradiated wastewater contains minor amounts of Zn and Cu than the soil (Table 4 & 5).
Iron (Fe) is one of the essential metals for human health. Still, the analytical result showed no Fe metal consumed by the Capsicum fruits, not even in the fruit samples nourished by only water and raw wastewater. The concentration of different nutrients such as sodium (Na), potassium (K), magnesium (Mg), and calcium (Ca), which are crucial for plant growth, found relatively more remarkable in the fruit samples of Capsicum plants cultivated by irradiated wastewater than the plants grown by only water and raw wastewater (Fig. 5b). Moreover, Na, K, and Mg had increased at a maximum level of 47.7%, 23.5% and 63.8%, respectively, for 10 KGy and the highest 50.0% rise in Ca concentration was found for 8 KGy among all the fruit samples. Different organic complexes were present in the raw wastewater with nutrient elements as ligands that become degraded at higher doses of gamma radiation and released into the wastewater as free elements (Paul et al. 2011; Parvin et al. 2015; Bhuiyan et al. 2015). As a result, these free macro and micronutrients can be uptaken easily by the plants when applied to them (Parvin et al. 2015). Also, high nutrients level was found due to increased root lengths of the Capsicum plants irrigated by irradiated wastewater (Begum et al. 2011; Bhuiyan et al. 2015).