The reduction of osteoporosis prevalence and incidence is critical due to the increase in the aging population in developing countries [14],[15]. Many studies have emphasized the importance of traditional Chinese medicine for treating osteoporosis and preventing fractures [9],[16, 17]. Among these medicines, GEJ has often been prescribed [18],[19]. In a clinical study, improvement in the BMD of the lumbar spine in postmenopausal women (mean age 54.8 [20],[21]) after three months of GEJ treatment was observed [11]. Unfortunately, most of the data analyzed in previous studies were obtained through the NHI database; thus, there is a lack of follow-up reports. Therefore, we set the first inclusion criterion to select osteoporosis patients who had undergone two DXA examinations to observe the effect of GEJ.
GEJ was the most prescribed formula at the CGMH, and the number of osteoporosis patients examined by DXA twice exceeded 40,000. However, only 218 patients were both administered GEJ and evaluated by DXA twice. The reason for this small number might be that some patients prescribed GEJ at the CGMH received DXA examination at other hospitals, leading to the loss of clinical data. While the data were anonymized and delinked, the DXA reporting forms and contents differed depending on the radiologist performing the evaluation. This also reduced the number of included patients. The results of a previous Taiwan NHI database study demonstrated that TCM use can decrease the rate of osteoporotic fracture [9]. In our study, GEJ was the main prescribed formula. However, our study results were not in agreement with the results of the aforementioned study. This might be due to the large difference in the total number of GEJ patients enrolled in our retrospective study.
Although we did not observe the expected results, we found that GEJ might improve osteoporosis of the lumbar spine. The number of fractures of the lumbar spine was significantly different (p = 0.034, Table 4). According to the results of previous studies, ginseng, a component of GEJ, can inhibit skeletal muscle atrophy, enhance muscle performance and improve blood circulation[22–25]. Another Chinese herb in the GEJ formula, lycium, can also improve muscle endurance [26]. These functions might help prevent elderly individuals from falling. This may be the reason the proportion of lumbar spine fractures in the study group was lower than that in the control group. Our database did not include the number of falls experienced by patients, which may be important data to analyze in our future studies. Although osteopenia at the hip joint was present in the study group, there was significant improvement in the patients’ condition. This indicates that GEJ may play an important role in the prevention of hip fractures [4] [27]. A previous animal study also showed that GEJ can be used to treat resorptive diseases, such as osteoporosis, by inhibiting osteoclast resorption [28]. This result is compatible with the results of our study. We demonstrated that patients administered a high GEJ dose of at least 600 pills in total had a lower incidence of fractures. This result may guide future studies.
This study has several limitations. First, the sample size of patients who received GEJ treatment was small, as DXA data could not be obtained from other hospitals. Second, investigations into the impact of ethical, psychological, and cultural factors were limited due to the nature of the database, which restricts investigations into differences between rural and urban areas.