In order to determine the most appropriate period to attempt recovery of a nerve and the corresponding innervated muscle, it is important to consider the changes that occur in both of them.
In nerve fibers which have undergone axotomy, it is known that the production of Nerve Growth Factor (NGF) reaches a maximum level after 24 hours and high levels of NGF are maintained at least two weeks after injury. The denervated muscle fibers however suffer atrophy and gradually lose tissue mass [22].
In muscle tissue denervated for a longer period of time i.e over 25 weeks, there is a significant reduction in the number of satellite cells [22]. Therefore muscles with a longer period of denervation do not present conditions for a possible reinnervation.
This was supported by another study [30] who conducted denervation of the pectoralis muscle of frog and observed, after nearly four years, the complete absence of muscle fibers.
Studies have been conducted evaluating the optimum time period for reinnervation in muscles with sectioned motor nerves. Some findings have suggested that the best time to receive new contact of motor nerve it would be between 12 and 16 weeks after surgery [23]. However, when there is no tissue loss, the faster the nerve repair attempt, better is the regeneration [23].
Classically, attempts of reinnervation of muscle would be performed as soon as possible. However on analyzing denervated muscles, muscle fibers are seen morphologically with characteristics of young fibers only after 12 weeks of denervation. The nerves play an important role in the modulation of such muscle fibers by changing its constitution or by modulating the different fiber types to better reach the functional demands of the muscle. Therefore in observing the natural development of striated skeletal muscles, a delay of several weeks may be more accurate than the immediate attempt of reinnervation, in particular if there is nerve tissue loss.
Recently, studies in rats have revealed that the gradual increase in muscle activity after targeted muscle reinnervation (TMR) takes place within 4 weeks. In comparison to normal muscle, the electromyography activity of the reinnervated muscle indicates an innerveration between the transferred nerve and the targeted muscle within four weeks after TMR surgery. In cases of amputees after TMR surgery, the muscle needs a long time to reinnervate and heal [31].
In this study, we conducted experimental lesions in rat sciatic nerve (with tissue loss) without recovery. The muscles chosen for morphological analysis of its recovery were the Soleus and EDL. The soleus muscle is considered as a postural muscle, which is rich in red fibers (type SO and FOG), and therefore more homogeneous, while EDL on the other hand is rich in white fibers (FG).
The present study demonstrated that the percentage of satellite cells decreases in soleus and EDL after denervation. The initial reaction in the EDL muscle after denervation is an increase in the percentage of satellite cells for a short period and then continues to decrease to near zero after 30 weeks. The increase in the percentage of satellite cells in soleus muscle also occurred in a short period of time after surgery.
The satellite cell population represents considerable potential for the postnatal growth of skeletal muscle [32] and the amount of satellite cells is dependent on nerve or muscle activity mediated by innervation. Their percentage is normal in reinnervated and regenerated muscles [33], but declines rapidly during regeneration deprived of innervation [34]. The events that occur in a denervated muscle can be described as slow and not synchronous [30, 34, 35]. Such events also affect the intrafusal fibers, where there is increase in their number [36].
We believe that the poor recovery of muscle strength after a significant delay in the surgical repair of the motor nerve is not only due to prevention of axonal regeneration through endoneurium, but also due to the decline of satellite cells in the muscle while it remained denervated for a long period.
Furthermore, our results show that the percentage of satellite cells in denervated muscle is similar to the percentage of satellite cells in normal muscle between the 16th and 19th week post-surgery.
From the results obtained in this research and with the aid of the literature it may be appropriate to infer that the optimum time period for reinnervation of a denervated muscle is between 16th and 19th weeks after surgery. During this time, the denervated muscle contains a similar amount of satellite cells to normal muscle, ultimately favoring muscle recovery.
In this study, the muscles in all the normal groups at the 38th week showed on an average 4 to 5 Intrafusal fiber. However, in the denervated groups of both the soleus and EDL muscles there is a statistically significant increase in the number of intrafusal fibers, directly proportional to the experimental time.
However, studies in humans on age related changes of the proprioceptive system with focus on muscle spindle showed a loss of intrafusal fibers per neuromuscular spindle which theoretically may be related to its own degeneration process [37].
Furthermore, the authors also suggest that these aforementioned changes related to aging are connected to an increased thickness of the connective capsule of the neuromuscular spindle. This is contrary to what we observed in our work, where only in the denervated groups; the connective capsule of neuromuscular spindles was altered showing a thickening of tissue around the intrafusal fibers.
This study demonstrates that there is an increase in the number of intrafusal fibers in the denervated group over a long period of time (38 weeks), where this increase is inversely proportional to the percentage of satellite cells. This correlation is considered statistically significant, suggesting that the increase of intrafusal fibers may be an attempt to maintain the muscular proprioceptive function.
We emphasize that this research can contribute to other studies on recovery of an injured muscle, as it suggests that the optimum period of reinnervation of a denervated muscle is between 16th and 19th week after denervation, during which the percentage of the satellite cells is similar that of the normal muscles. The results also demonstrate that with the increase in the period of denervation, the number of intrafusal fibers increases, suggesting that even during degeneration of muscle, intrafusal fibers increase in number in order to maintain proprioceptive and sensory functions.
In summary, further research is necessary to complement our findings in developing an ideal time frame for reinnervation for recovery of injured muscle and motor nerves.