Due to the mechanical characteristics of the fracture site, improper selection of internal fixation, concomitant osteoporosis, and other factors, the incidence of postoperative internal fixation failure is approximately 4–20% in elderly patients with comminuted femoral intertrochanteric fractures [9, 10]. Therefore, arthroplasty has been recognized as an acceptable treatment for these patients [11], including the use of cemented prostheses [12] and biological fixation methods [13]. Hip prostheses result in favorable clinical outcomes, allowing for patients to get out of bed early, reducing postoperative complications, and improving the patients’ quality of life. However, fixation of the greater trochanter during hip joint replacement surgery is challenging. This study presents an effective method for the treatment of unstable intertrochanteric fractures in the elderly.
A novel classification system for greater trochanter fractures
A novel classification system for greater trochanter fractures, based on the Evans-Jensen types III and V fractures has been introduced in this study. The specific fracture and displacement of the greater trochanter fracture in the Evans-Jensen classification system has not been analyzed thoroughly. The new classification system is mainly based on the displacement direction and location of the greater trochanter fracture line. This new system aims to result in better fixation of greater trochanter fractures. Among the 38 patients in this study, two had type A fractures, four had type B1 fractures, 24 had type B2 fractures, and eight had type C fractures. Overall, 18 patients had simple fractures of the greater trochanter (two-part fractures) and 20 patients had comminuted fractures (≥ three-part fractures). Several muscles, including the gluteus medius and gluteus minimus, attach to the greater trochanter. The main pulling direction of the gluteus medius is upward and backward; therefore, the greater trochanter will be displaced in this direction if fractured. This anatomy accounts for the high proportion of patients with type B2 fractures in this study. The direction of intraoperative wire binding and compression must be determined based on the direction of the displacement of the greater trochanter, and the direction of intraoperative wire compression should be the opposite of the direction of the bone block pulling to resist the force of fracture displacement. In this study, the ventral compression fixation achieved using steel wire tension bands based on the new classification system resulted in favorable fixations.
Clinical efficacy of steel wire tension bands according to the new classification system
Several fixation methods are currently used to treat greater trochanter fractures, though these methods are complicated by fixation failure, osteolysis, and prosthesis loosening, which is a common cause of hip revision surgery [14]. Jeffrey et al. [15] reported the use of a claw plate to fix greater trochanter fractures during hip arthroplasty. Three of the 31 patients in their study developed greater trochanter bursitis with obvious pain in the lateral hip that improved after the removal of the plate. Three patients in the previous study experienced bone nonunion and one patient had an infection. No patients in the current study reported lateral hip pain, which may be due to the fact that the steel wire and the steel plate are relatively small, resulting in less irritation to the soft tissue. The large claw plate likely results in squeezing of the bursa and friction, leading to bursitis. An in vitro model was used to determine the usefulness of a cable binding system to fix greater tuberosity fractures in a previous study [16]. This system has a stronger biomechanical structure; however, contact between the rough cable and the femoral stem resulted in metal particles that caused prosthesis loosening. In this study, a steel wire tension band was used to fix the steel wire. The steel wire is relatively smooth and is not associated with complications of metal particles. Another study including three patients with greater trochanter fractures reported the use of a steel plate combined with a steel cable to fix the greater tuberosity [17]. In this previous study, all three patients had loosening and displacement of the steel cable, resulting in fixation failure. The fixation failure was attributed to the fixed steel cable and a problem with the pressurizing device. The pressurization of the steel wire is dependent on the twisting and pressurization between the two ends of the steel wire, which is simple, convenient, and intuitive. Takahira et al. [18] used steel cables and steel plates to fix greater trochanter fractures during hip arthroplasty and reported complications including fractures of the steel cables and bone resorption around the steel cables. Compressed steel cables are stronger than steel wires or steel cables. As joint replacement surgeries are typically conducted in elderly patients, the use of steel cable may lead to accidental fractures during compression. In this study, the Harris hip function score, Parker activity score, and pain score were significantly improved during the follow-up period. The greater trochanter fracture healed well, and only one patient had wire breakage. There were no common complications including greater trochanter bursitis, osteolysis caused by metal wear, or prosthesis loosening.
Ventral compression fixation with steel wire tension band
Steel wire tying is essential for ventral compression fixation with steel wire tension bands. Tension band fixation technology has achieved satisfactory results as a standard internal fixation method for patella and olecranon fractures, which are similar to greater trochanter fractures [19, 20]. The compression and stabilization technology of the ventral fracture surface in the band fixation technique is important. If there is no ventral compression, the failure rate of internal fixation is greatly increased. However, ventral compression has previously been ignored in the banding technology of greater trochanter fractures [21, 22]. The fixation effect achieved using this technology is reliable, even when the greater trochanter fracture is comminuted. As the greater trochanter is attached to the tough muscle fascia, steel wire can be used during fixation. Banding fixation can be used to suture comminuted fracture fragments and preserve the blood supply of the fracture fragments, which aids in fracture healing.
For type A fractures, a ring-shaped steel wire and a figure eight-shaped steel wire are used for fixation. The ring-shaped steel wire is wound from the tip of the greater trochanter to the lower part of the lesser trochanter and is fixed on the ventral side posterolaterally from the greater trochanter. The figure eight-shaped steel wire surrounds the fractured portion. For type B fractures, two steel wires are used during fixation. The ring-shaped steel wire fixation is the same as that for type A fractures, while the direction of the figure eight-shaped steel wire is dependent on the direction of the fracture line. Type B1 fractures are fixed in the posterolateral direction of the greater trochanter, and type B2 fractures are fixed in the anterolateral direction of the rotor. For type C fractures, three or more steel wires are generally used for fixation. The first ring steel wire is the same as that for type A fractures, the second ring steel wire is wound below the lesser trochanter perpendicular to the fracture line for ring fixation, and the third figure eight-shaped steel wire achieves compression fixation on the opposite side of the fracture line. When the fracture line is inferior to the lesser trochanter, one or more steel wires can be added below the lesser trochanter for ring fixation.
Limitations
This study is not without limitations. It is a retrospective study that includes a small number of patients and a relatively short follow-up period, which may affect the reliability of the data. In addition, no control group was included. Therefore, a large-scale, long-term follow-up study that includes a control group is needed.