We investigated the relationship between the risk of breast cancer and XRCC3 Thr241Met, XRCC4 G(-1394)T, BAX G(-248)A, BCL2 C(-938)A gene polymorphisms. These genes code for the proteins enrolled in DNA injury repair and apoptosis which are important processes in carcinogenesis. Several studies addressed the polymorphisms on these genes. The results from the previous studies show variations. The genetic differences endemic in a geographical area could be one of the reasons. The frequency of genetic variants associated with a gene polymorphism in a particular population is an important determinant of the breast cancer risk. Thus, differences in the incidence of variant alleles associated with a polymorphism among societies may lead to different results.
In our study, women with homozygote BAX -248A allele (AA genotype) had 5 times more risk of developing breast cancer. In addition, status of metastasis and tumor size were associated with this genotype. These findings were similar with the study of Kholoussi et al. [8]. They found that presence of heterozygote variant BAX -248A allele (GA genotype) was associated with higher grade (grade 3 or more), T2 status and having lobular disease. Similar results were obtained in homozygote and heterozygote BAX -248A variant alleles (GA genotype + AA genotype), thus making BAX G(-248)A -248A variant allele as the “risk allele”.
The relationship between BAX G(-248)A gene polymorphism and clinical parameters in different types of cancer has been studied previously with various different results. Wang et. al. studied the effects of BAX G(-248)A gene polymorphism and survival in gastric cancer patients receiving postoperative chemotherapy. In their study, having at least one variant genotype in BAX G(-248)A was associated with increase in the recurrence risk and poorly affecting survival [9]. Gu et. al. studied the relationship of BAX G(-248)A gene polymorphism and hematological toxicity in patients with advanced stage small cell lung cancer receiving platinum based chemotherapy. They showed that BAX G(-248)A gene polymorphism did not affect survival [10]
The analysis we conducted on XRCC3 Thr241Met polymorphism portrayed that, homozygote expression of 241Met allele (241Met/Met) was associated with 3 times increased risk of developing breast cancer. This genotype was also associated with clinical stages of III+IV. Chai et al. performed a meta-analysis on XRCC3 Thr241Met gene polymorphism and breast cancer arriving at similar results as our study. In that study having 241 Met/Met genotype in XRCC3 Thr241Met gene polymorphism was reported as a risk factor for breast cancer especially in the Asian population [11]. Qureshi et al. studied the effects of XRCC3 (Thr241Met) gene polymorphism and breast cancer and their results were similar with our study [12]. In their study 241Met/Met genotype was associated with 1.5 times increased risk of developing breast cancer. Similar results as our study were obtained by Jara et al., who studied the effects of XRCC3 Thr241Met gene polymorphism and breast cancer [13]. It was shown that XRCC3 241Met allele carriers had increased risk of developing breast cancer. Smith et al.’s study on the same relationship with breast cancer patients and healthy controls was in parallel with our study, finding to relationship with XRCC3 Thr241Met gene polymorphism and breast cancer [14]. On the other hand, in the study by Romanowicz H et al. investigating the relationship between DNA repair gene polymorphisms and breast cancer; XRCC3 Thr241Met gene polymorphism was not associated with the risk of breast cancer [15]. The relationship between XRCC3 Thr241Met gene polymorphism and breast cancer was not studied previously. Nonetheless, Ji et. al. showed that XRCC3 Thr241Met gene polymorphism did not have an effect on response to chemotherapy treatment and overall survival in osteosarcoma patients [16].
In our study, we did not find a relationship with BCL2 C(-938)A gene polymorphism and breast cancer like Searle et al. [17]. Neither breast cancer nor the lymph node involvement related survival were associated with this polymorphism. Zhang et al. conducted a study on investigating the relationship between BCL2 C(-938)A gene polymorphism and breast cancer. They found that patients with AA genotype had 2.37 times more risk of developing breast cancer than people with AC and CC genotypes [18]. This genotype was related with lymph node positivity and pathological diagnosis. The incidence of the genotypes in the study group (based on the control group) were: 7.5% was AA, 49.5% was AC and 43% was CC. In our study, 31% was AA, 48% was CA and 21% was AA genotype in the control group. The difference in the incidence of AA genotype between the two populations could be the reason for the absence of a relationship between breast cancer and BCL2 C(-938)A gene polymorphism in our study (7.5% vs 31%). Bhushann et al. showed the relationship between this polymorphism and breast cancer in contrast with our study [19].
In our study, no statistically significant relationship was found between XRCC4 G(-1394)T gene polymorphism and breast cancer. In the study of Chiu et al., on the other hand, homozygote or heterozygote expression of –1394T allele increased the risk of breast cancer. The difference between this study and our study could result from the difference in the incidence of the variant allele [20]. While the incidence of these variant allele as homozygote was 0% in that study, it was 43% in our study. In their meta-analysis Zhou et al. showed the relationship with this polymorphism and breast cancer [21]. Romanowicz et al. [15] and Saadat et al. [22] did not find a relationship with this polymorphism and breast cancer in parallel with our study.
Apoptosis and DNA repair are important processes establishing the road leading to cancer development. The proteins utilized during these process play important roles. Gene polymorphism have key roles in the activity of these proteins. The risks and roles of these polymorphisms and their relationship with clinical parameters have been shown in the literature. Our study have shown that these polymorphisms have significant roles in the development of breast cancer, studying four different gene polymorphisms in the Turkish population for the first time