3.1 H2S Adsorption Study
To understand the performance of nitrogen modified PSAC adsorbents towards H2S removal, the adsorbents that were synthesized via thermal heating (PSAC_TH) and microwave heating (PSAC_MW) were analysed by using H2S adsorption study. The physical and chemical characteristics of the modified adsorbents were investigated and will be discussed in detail in the following sections. Commercial raw palm shell activated carbon (PSAC) adsorbent was used as a baseline to evaluate the performance of the nitrogen modified adsorbents in this work. To be noted, the nitrogen modified adsorbents that were synthesized via conventional thermal and MW heating methods were performed under similar parameters.
Figure 3 illustrated the H2S breakthrough curves for all PSAC-based adsorbents (PSAC, PSAC-TH and PSAC-MW). Among all, the breakthrough curve of PSAC-MW shows better performance, due to it shows prolonged breakthrough time and extended exhaustion time compared to the PSAC and PSAC-TH. The breakthrough capacity was calculated at breakthrough time, where Ci/Co= 0.05 and the total adsorption capacity was calculated at Ci/Co = 0.95 (exhaustion time), where Ci is the H2S concentration at time t and Co is the H2S’s inlet concentration. Theoretically, the H2S breakthrough capacity is defined as the mass of the adsorbate (H2S) removed by the adsorbent at breakthrough concentration or the maximum acceptable (desired), while the total H2S adsorption capacity is defined as the total mass of the adsorbate (H2S) removed by the adsorbent when the outlet concentration of H2S is almost saturated or at exhaustion time (Shang et al. 2012). The H2S breakthrough-curve characteristics along with the pH values of the adsorbents are shown in Table 1.
Table 1
H2S breakthrough-curve characteristics and pH values of PSAC-based adsorbents
Sample
|
pH
|
Breakthrough time, t0.05 (min)
|
Exhaustion time, t0.95 (min)
|
Breakthrough capacity (mg/g)
|
Total adsorption capacity (mg/g)
|
PSAC
|
7.48
|
2.0
|
116.17
|
3.25
|
61.14
|
PSAC-TH
|
8.02
|
30.0
|
150.33
|
32.57
|
78.31
|
PSAC-MW
|
8.31
|
87.17
|
771.0
|
94.20
|
356.94
|
Compared to the PSAC and PSAC-TH, the PSAC-MW shows the highest H2S breakthrough capacity and total adsorption capacity, with 94.20 mg/g and 356.94 mg/g, respectively. From results in Table 1, the presence of surface basicity with a pH value of 8.31 indicates that it influences the adsorption capacity of the PSAC-MW. The PSAC-MW had the highest surface basicity compared to others. Thus, it can be presumed that the basicity is one of the factors that could lead to the efficient H2S adsorption. The presence of surface basicity in the adsorbent could improve the chemisorption of acidic H2S to sulfur (S). The chemisorption caused more S deposited onto the adsorbent, in which the dissociation of H2S covalent bond with nitrogen functional groups tailored happened. As reported by (Adib et al. 2000), the presence of basicity condition of the adsorbent with a typical pH value in the range of 6 to 8 could contribute to high oxidation of H2S. In this work, the pH values of the PSAC-TH and PSAC-MW are pH 8.02 and 8.31, respectively, which indicates the PSAC-TH was less basic compared to the PSAC-MW. However, the same trend was not observed in the raw PSAC sample, where there is no nitrogen modification involved. This finding supports the high adsorption capacity of H2S using PSAC-MW adsorbent.
3.2 Effect of Surface Characteristics
Generally, high H2S adsorption capacity is frequently related to adsorbent’s surface area, type of porous structure, available surface functional groups, and the possible chemisorption that might occurred within the adsorbent structure (Bazan-Wozniak et al. 2017). The physical and surface properties of the PSAC-based adsorbents are shown in Table 2. From the results, it seems the MW heating method could improve the physical characteristics of the nitrogen modified PSAC-based adsorbent, especially on surface area and pore structures. Referring to the previous works, impregnation of urea via conventional thermal heating method, results in enhancement of physical structure of carbon materials (Adib et al. 2000; Seredych and Bandosz 2008; Nowicki et al. 2015; Kaźmierczak-Raźna et al. 2019; Saad et al. 2020). Similar trend was observed in surface properties of the PSAC-TH, where its surface area and pore structure were well developed compared to the raw PSAC. (Adib et al. 2000) reported, AC that was undergo high thermal heating at temperature of 950°C, would reduce the carbon grains for about 30%, due to the increase in the adsorption energy. In consequence, this justifies the significance of the PSAC-TH’s surface area was reduced by 10% compared to the raw PSAC.
Table 2
Physical and surface properties of PSAC-based adsorbents
Sample
|
BET surface area (m2/g)
|
Micropore volume (cm3/g)
|
Total pore volume (cm3/g)
|
Average pore width (nm)
|
Vmic/Vt
|
PSAC
|
957.00
|
0.40
|
0.51
|
2.15
|
0.78
|
PSAC-TH
|
896.30
|
0.30
|
0.47
|
2.12
|
0.63
|
PSAC-MW
|
1000.62
|
0.35
|
0.51
|
2.03
|
0.69
|
Figure 4 shows the relationship between total surface area and total H2S adsorption capacity that was further investigated by using nitrogen-modified PSAC-based adsorbents that were synthesized at different MW heating temperature, ranging from 500 to 900°C. The increase in MW heating temperature, caused enhancement in the PSAC’s surface structure, where an increase in surface area of the adsorbents were observed. This clarifies that the increase in MW heating temperature could improves the degree of surface area development. Additionally, with the influence of nitrogen functional groups, the enhancement in surface area and porous structures offering spacious space to collect the H2S, which indirectly increase the total H2S adsorption capacity, as in MW900 performance. From Fig. 4, at 500°C of MW heating temperature, the total H2S adsorption capacity is only 161.5 mg/g, whereas at 900°C of MW heating temperature, the total H2S adsorption capacity is up to 356.9 mg/g. This contributes a remarkable difference in the H2S adsorption capacity when the MW heating temperature increased. Surface characteristics of the PSAC-MW adsorbents play an essential role in the accessibility of nitrogen functional groups integration into the carbon structures. The influence of basicity in the PSAC-MW adsorbent could further assist in the chemisorption of H2S, where the adsorbent small and narrow pore structures could help to immobilize the H2S. Consequently, an increase in H2S adsorption capacity was observed by the PSAC-MW adsorbent, as increase in MW heating temperature.
The growth in surface properties of the nitrogen-modified PSAC-based adsorbent is presumed related to the mechanism of MW heating itself. During the MW heating, carbon material is subjected to the electromagnetic field, where the delocalized π-electrons start to move through the broad areas within the material (Kaźmierczak-Raźna et al. 2019). (Menéndez et al. 2010) explained, carbon material that was subjected to the electromagnetic and induced current heating can further rise to hot spot establishment at a very high temperature, which indirectly subject to the absorption of MW energy into the carbon material. The hot spot establishment via MW heating is recognized as a great development for the adsorbent itself. The hot spot was discovered during the MW heating study as shown in Fig. 5. The hot spot was seen in red coloured, in the middle of the adsorbent’s placement inside the Quartz column.
The correlation between pore size distribution and their involvement onto the porosity of the PSAC-based adsorbents is shown in Fig. 6. The PSAC-MW has high pore volume for average diameter of < 20 Å of pore width, which exhibits well pore distributions. Based on the average pore diameter, the PSAC-MW pore width was narrower and had the highest pore volume compared to the PSAC and PSAC-TH. (Ren et al. 2020) suggested that carbon adsorbent that has small pore structure, preferably in micropore size are efficient for H2S adsorption to be happened. The micropore size of the PSAC-MW could confine the H2S molecules within the pores whilst keeping the molecules from escaping from the carbon material. The H2S is a small molecule with a diameter of 3.6 Å (Shah et al. 2017), in which smaller pore structure is more preferrable for the physisorption and chemisorption to occur. This occurrence may possibly improve the ability of H2S adsorption, in which the reaction between the H2S and nitrogen functional groups could effortlessly happen via trapping the gas molecules into smaller and narrower pore structure. The shrinkage of pore width in the MW modified adsorbent provides better structures compared to the PSAC, where the H2S molecules could be trapped and adsorbed more. This theory can be applied for both PSAC-TH and PSAC-MW. The same trend was observed in the nitrogen modified PSAC-based adsorbents at different MW heating temperature (Fig. 7), where their micropore volumes observed were lesser than the PSAC. As increase in the MW heating temperature, the micropore volume of the adsorbents seem to be improved. Pore size distribution of the adsorbents at different MW heating temperatures indicates an increment in the micropore volume of pore widths < 40 Å.
3.3 Effect of Surface Chemistry
The results of proximate and elemental analysis of the PSAC-based adsorbents are presented in Table 3, whereas the elemental distribution of the adsorbents is illustrated in Fig. 8. The proximate analysis of all samples shows a high percentage in carbon content, which indicates the main component of the adsorbent is activated carbon. Compared to the nitrogen modified adsorbents, the PSAC was rich in volatile and moisture content. The elemental analysis data show significant amounts of nitrogen element in the PSAC-TH and PSAC-MW compared to the PSAC. The presence of nitrogen element in both PSAC-TH and PSAC-MW are owing to the easiness of nitrogen functional groups incorporated into the carbon matrix as aromatic ring component, especially at high temperature (Li et al. 2020). Thus, the use of high temperature (950°C) in producing both PSAC-TH and PSAC-MW, assisted in the integration of nitrogen functional groups into the carbon matrix. It was observed that the PSAC-MW contains higher nitrogen content (2.89 %) compared to the PSAC-TH (0.49%). Apart from that, an increase in carbon content for both PSAC-TH and PSAC-MW was also observed. The increase in the carbon content was due to the high degree of re-heating during the pyrolysis process of the modified adsorbents that underwent both thermal and MW heating. Besides the influence of high MW temperature, high surface area of the PSAC-MW (1000.62 m2/g) is another factor that allows the accessibility of nitrogen functional groups to be integrated into carbon’s crystalline edges. This finding strengthens the theory that the use of MW heating possibly will enhance the AC characteristics that consists of high content of heteroatom (in this case nitrogen functional groups). The significant amount of nitrogen functional groups in the adsorbents helps in the adsorption of H2S. Consequently, adsorbent that has high nitrogen content is relatively promotes to high H2S adsorption capacity, as shown by the PSAC-MW (Table 1).
Table 3
Proximate and elemental analysis of PSAC-based adsorbents
Sample
|
Proximate Analysis (wt %)
|
Elemental Analysis (wt %)
|
Carbon
|
Moisture
|
Volatile
|
Ash
|
C
|
H
|
N
|
S
|
PSAC
|
78.20
|
6.05
|
9.61
|
6.14
|
61.61
|
1.48
|
-
|
-
|
PSAC-TH
|
87.53
|
4.78
|
5.32
|
2.37
|
79.92
|
0.90
|
0.49
|
-
|
PSAC-MW
|
90.38
|
2.16
|
5.72
|
1.74
|
88.76
|
1.50
|
2.89
|
-
|
From Fig. 8, a substantial amount of nitrogen content and an increase in carbon content were identified in all nitrogen-modified adsorbents, which consistent with nitrogen to carbon (N/C) ratio. The increase in carbon content in the nitrogen-modified adsorbent is relative to the raise of MW temperature. This happened due to the high degree of carbonization during the pyrolysis process of urea impregnated PSAC that experiences both thermal and MW heating, where the adsorbent encounters twofold of high temperature, where the first one is during the production of AC (before urea impregnation). Nevertheless, as for hydrogen content, the amounts are significantly reduced as the MW temperature raised.
To investigate the influence of urea impregnation and MW heating method on the surface chemistry of the PSAC-MW, FTIR analysis has been performed as illustrated in Fig. 9. All adsorbents show significant spectrums between bands 600 to 900 cm−1, which indicates various positions of hydrogen in aromatic rings, mostly out of plane deformation of C–H group that was located at the edge of the aromatic group (Simons 1978). Additionally, the spectrums detected all through the bands of 1150, 1300, 1600 and 1800 cm−1 are signifying the functional groups of –C–O and O–H stretches and bends that can be classified into alcohols and phenols (R–OH), ethers (R–O–R), hydrocarbon attached to oxygen (–O–R), ketones, aldehydes, carboxylic acids, esters, and organic carbonates (Simons 1978). Due to urea impregnation, the functional groups identified in nitrogen modified PSAC adsorbents were different at certain bands compared to the raw PSAC. The reaction of carboxylic and aromatic groups with urea at high temperature (950°C) increase in the bands’ intensity at 850, 1300, 1600, 2250, and 3200 cm−1 wavelengths. This indicated that there was association of nitrogen occurred after the impregnation of urea. As there was an increase in the intensity of the bands, strong aromatic C–N stretch peaks at 1300 cm−1 had been incorporated into the carbon structures. The band at 1600 cm−1 was possibly the C=O stretch of amides and imides groups that have been incorporated with the NH2 scissors group, while the band at 2250 cm−1 was presumed to be the nitriles group that comprise of C≡N stretches of nitriles and the band at 3200 cm−1 was the vibration of NH2 and N–H stretches. The PSAC-MW exhibited strong intensity of the nitrogen functional groups compared to the PSAC-TH.
3.4 Effect of Thermal Analysis
Thermal stability analysis of the PSAC-based adsorbents is shown in Fig. 10 and Fig. 11. The DTG (differential thermal gravimetry) curve can be classified into three different ranges, which are from 80 – 120°C, 150 – 450°C, and 500 – 950°C. The first range of the DTG curve denotes the weight loss of moisture in the material, where it typically contributed to substantial percentage of weight loss (Bazan et al. 2016). The weight loss of absorbed water for the PSAC-TH is the highest (4.8 %/°C) followed by the PSAC (4 %/°C), and the PSAC-MW (3 %/°C). This implied that the PSAC-based adsorbents contain hydrophilic characteristic that tend to absorb water. Hence, the PSAC-based adsorbent is recommended to be stored in a desiccator that contains silica gel, to prevent the humidity in the air affecting or deteriorating the adsorbents. The second range of the DTG curve represents the decomposition of volatile organic matters that are easily volatile, presence on the surface of activated carbon such as carboxylic groups (Bazan et al. 2016). Fig. 10 displays that both the PSAC-TH and PSAC-MW experience higher weight loss of volatile organic matters compared to the PSAC. This is due to both the PSAC-TH and PSAC-MW were impregnated with urea, which had high intensity of carboxylic group (refer to Fig. 9). The nitrogen modified adsorbents were exposed at high temperature and experienced significant weight loss of 5 – 6 %/°C. This happened because of rapid decomposition of urea-derived species and other organic components in the range of 500 – 700°C as indicated in the DTG curves. These nitrogen functional groups were identified as amide, imide, nitrile groups and pyridine nitrogen. This explains the theory studied by (Seredych and Bandosz 2008), where the nitrogen-modified adsorbent that was heated at high temperature is very stable. As increases in the MW heating temperature from 500 – 900°C for, the weight loss in the nitrogen modified adsorbents shows rapid decomposition of urea-derived species (nitrogen functional groups) and other organic components in the range of 500 – 700˚C in the DTG curve. The DTG curve for the PSAC adsorbents at lower MW temperatures (MW500, MW600, MW700) shows significant weight losses compared to the MW900.
3.5 Effect of Surface Morphology
The surface morphology of the nitrogen-modified PSAC-based adsorbents is shown in Fig. 12. All adsorbents had been subjected to the SEM analysis at a magnification of 5kX. Apparently, the nitrogen modified PSAC-based adsorbents showed different pattern compared to the PSAC. The surface morphology of the PSAC-TH in Fig. 12 (b) displays the pore structure had been clogged by excess urea/impurities and the size of the pores seems smaller compared to the PSAC structure in Figure 12 (a). As for the PSAC-MW in Figure 12 (c), the pore structure was well-developed and fewer pores had been clogged with urea/impurities as in the PSAC-TH. Furthermore, the carbon structure in the PSAC-MW established the sponge-like structure, where there is another pore were being constructed inside the existing pores and the pore size observed was smaller compared to the PSAC-TH and PSAC. As discussed earlier, narrow pore size could assist in H2S adsorption activity. Thus, the surface morphology of the PSAC-MW justified the relationship between physical surface characteristics data in Table 2 and its surface morphology, where it contributes to high H2S adsorption capacity. As reported by (Halasz et al. 2010), the use of MW heating method on AC could significantly change the amorphous structure of AC, where the cavities were deepened, and the inner structure of the adsorbent was remarkable. The development of surface area and narrow pore structures in the PSAC-MW were clearly noticed and this confirmed the hypothesis, where additional pores have been developed inside the pores (as observed from the surface morphology). These new added pores were assumed to have additional pore created inside the structure (sponge-like structure) as the mechanism of MW heating itself is irradiated from the inner to the outer surface of the material. Having evaluated the thermal heating method on the PSAC-TH, it appears to have a slight identical effect as the PSAC-MW on the morphology of the AC.
The surface morphology of the PSAC adsorbents that have been modified with urea under different MW heating temperatures is shown in Fig. 13. For the nitrogen modified PSAC adsorbents that undergo different MW heating temperatures, as increases in temperature, the fouling of urea on the adsorbent surface seems to be better, as well as the development of the pore structure. This caused in the increases of H2S adsorption capacity as increases in the MW heating temperature. Fig. 14 shows surface morphology of the nitrogen modified PSAC was also tested on MW heating time parameter, where the shortest heating time = 10 min and the longest heating time 60 min. The nitrogen modified PSAC at 10 min of heating time exhibited uniform porous structure, where the pore walls were not disturbed compared to the nitrogen modified PSAC at 60 min of MW heating time. The sintering effect of the carbon structure at 60 min of heating time was probably due to the pore walls between the adjacent pores that were destroyed. This resulted in widening the micropores and mesopores, which led to the external shrinkage and collapse of the carbon framework. In addition, instead of longer heating time, the use of high MW heating temperature (950°C) could be one of the factors that facilitated the destruction of pore structure once exposed at a longer heating time (Nor et al. 2016). Thus, this occurrence explains the H2S adsorption capacity toward MW heating time, where at short heating time (10 min), resulted to high removal of H2S.
3.6 Conventional Thermal Heating versus MW Heating Method
Based on the above discussions, MW heating method shows promising performance on the H2S adsorption capacity compared to conventional thermal heating method. The great performance of the MW heating method can be related to its heating mechanism, where the theory was deduced by (Garcia Reimbert et al. 1996). Referring to the theory, a carbon material that was exposed to induced currents (origin from electromagnetic field) would be heated due to electrical resistances within the material. These electromagnetic and thermal properties of the material were non-linear temperature dependent. Thus, if the rate of material’s absorption of MW non-linearly increased with heating temperature, a non- uniform heating would be created within the material, and indirectly formed regions of very high temperature known as hot spot.
The formation of the hot spot shown in Fig. 5 throughout the MW heating can be defined as sparks or electric arcs, where it could be regarded as plasma at the microscopic level. According to (Rodriguez-Fernandez et al. 2020), these plasmas could be considered as microplasmas and they were observed as the very tiny sparks that could last for a fraction of a second. Activated carbon is a good MW absorber and it could enhance the hot spot formation. Since the temperatures of these hot spots were considerably higher, this occurrence increased the kinetic energy of π-electrons (make the electrons jump out of the substance) and ionized the surrounding atmosphere of the material (Menéndez et al. 2010). During the MW heating process, the hot spot was believed to be responsible for the development of physical and chemical characteristics of PSAC-MW. Referring to all the reasons, the MW heating method was chosen over the conventional thermal heating method.