Computational redesign of AspB.
We commenced our study by defining calculation criteria based on the detailed enzymatic mechanism. Although thermodynamically feasible, hydroamination reactions generally have a high activation barrier due to the repulsion of the electron-rich π-system of the alkene substrate and the electron pair on the amine nitrogen atom28. However, the entropic penalty can conceivably be overcome by preorganization in an enzyme reactive site15. The reaction mechanism of AspB involves the abstraction of the pro-R proton from the Cβ atom of substrate aspartate by the general base Ser318 within the SS loop29. The carboxylate group of the formed enolate anion intermediate is stabilized through a network of hydrogen bonds including residues Thr101, Ser140, Thr141, and Ser319, with the amino group being easily accommodated in the nucleophile binding pocket by hydrogen-bonding interactions of the side chains of Thr101, Asn142, and His18830. The original α-carboxylate binding pocket consists of residues Thr187, Met321, Lys324, and Asn326, which were substituted to target different electrophiles in our previous work20. Initial experiments on the asymmetric hydroamination reaction of amine groups revealed that Asn142 served as a dispensable residue, whereas Thr101 and His188 functioned as crucial residues, i.e., substitutions of Thr101 and His188 to alanine provoked dramatic reductions in catalytic activities. From the structural point of view, residues Ala99, Leu358, and Glu362 create a hindered environment to suppress the amine group from entering its ideal reactive pose. Motivated by these findings, we performed computational redesign to expand the nucleophile spectrum of AspB. Specifically, Ala99, Asn142, Leu358, and Glu362 were envisioned to be mutated into less-bulky residues while the global folding of the enzyme was maintained. In addition, the hydrogen-bonding interaction network of the β-carboxylate was preserved in the near-attack conformation during the design process (Fig. 2).
Conjugate addition of a matrix of nucleophilic donors to electrophilic acceptors by computationally redesigned AspB.
We first evaluated the asymmetric hydroamination of crotonic acid (1) with amine derivatives. As the benchmark reactions for computational design, substrates that provides an exceptional opportunity for late-stage diversification (allylamine, h) or bears relatively larger substituents (cyclopropylamine, j) were chosen. A mutant library of the B19 enzyme20 was generated in silico by simultaneous substitutions of Ala99, Asn142, Leu358, and Glu362 to less-bulky residues (A99 to G, N142 to GAVSTC, L358 to GAVIMSTCDNH, and E362 to GAVLIMSTCDNH). Experimental validation of a small set of 22 designs for 1 h and 16 designs for 1j resulted in the identification of 37 mutants, among which the referred BA15 design (containing A99G-N142S-T187C-M231I-K324L-N326A-L358V-E362M mutations) showed the highest specific activity for syntheses of both 1 h and 1j as ascertained by HPLC with a chemically prepared authentic standard. Excellent conversions (> 99%) were achieved within 2 h with only < 0.005 mol% biocatalyst, and control experiments showed that the amines did not react with crotonic acid in the absence of the enzymes. The successful design encouraged the evaluation of a broad spectrum of compounds (a-n), in which most of the amines were efficiently converted by BA15 to afford the respective optically pure products (> 99% e.e.) with > 96% conversions (Fig. 3C) at a substrate loading up to 150 g/L. Notably, sterically hindered amines (c and e), which were problematic substrates for previously reported enzymatic hydroamination reactions, were successfully catalytically incorporated. For strong nucleophile ethylenediamine (m), weak spontaneous reaction occurred, which gave a slight drop of product enantioselectivity to 90% e.e. Structural analysis showed that A99G-N142S-L358V-E362M mutations would afford an enlarged amine binding pocket that would retain the van der Waals interactions and permit the binding of bulkier amine groups in different orientations (Fig. 3A). Hence, nonnative amines with charged or large substituents might be accepted in addition to simple ammonia. More importantly, the conformational change of the nucleophilic pocket was considered to not conflict with the electrophilic pocket, which raised the possibility of direct combination of the nucleophilic and electrophilic pockets without multiple rounds of design.
To evaluate the compatibility of the nucleophilic pocket and designed electrophilic pockets, the redesigned nucleophile binding pocket was introduced into the AspB wild type (yielded AA15 design containing A99G-N142S-L358V-E362M mutations) and its engineered enzymes P1 (yielded PA15 design containing A99G-N142S-T187C-M231I-K324L-N326C-L358V-E362M mutations) and F2920 (yielded FA15 design containing A99G-N142S-T187C-M231V-K324I-N326C-L358V-E362M mutations) to catalyze the conjugate addition of a matrix of diverse nucleophilic donors to electrophilic acceptors. As anticipated, the unsaturated amino acids bearing an ethyl group efficiently underwent a hydroamination reaction with the evaluated amines to afford the corresponding products in excellent conversions (> 94%) and enantioselectivities (> 99% e.e., expect for 2 m). The substrate tolerances peaked at concentration up to 100 g/L. For charged substrate fumaric acid, most of the substituted amines with aliphatic, unsaturated, or charged groups were efficiently processed, providing the desired products > 90% conversions and excellent stereoselectivity (> 99% e.e., expect for 3 m) at a high substrate loading of 80–130 g/L, except for isopropylamine and cyclobutylamine, which gave moderate conversions (88% and 79%, respectively). For aromatic substrates, a lower concentration (7.5 g/L) had to be used due to their low solubility. Amines with relatively small substituents exhibited low conversions. Nonetheless, cinnamic acid was proven to be a competent coupling partner with methoxyamine, providing the product with 97% conversion. Aromatic acrylates bearing election-withdrawing/-donating groups also afforded desired products with satisfactory conversions, which demonstrates the compatibility of the redesigned enzyme to tolerate functionalized groups typically encountered in pharmaceutical agents.
For a few ncAAs bearing valuable scaffolds or providing opportunities for further functionalization, preparative reactions were performed. As summarized in Fig. 3C, various ncAA products were successfully synthesized by the corresponding redesigned AspBs on ten to hundred gram scales to afford the products in good to excellent isolated yields (74–93%). Remarkably, propargylamine was efficiently converted to give the corresponding product 1i in excellent isolated yield (93%, 131 g), leaving the alkynyl group available for potential downstream synthetic manipulation. With a 1.5-fold molar equiv. of propargylamine over crotonic acid, the reactions were complete within 1 h at 50 °C, providing the space-time yield of 131 g/L/h, which is, to our knowledge, the highest value reported to date for C-N lyases. Within the rather broad substrate spectrum, we next examined substrates with long aliphatic chains that are precursors of aspartame derivatives. Derivatization of the artificial dipeptide sweetener aspartame with N-alkyl groups can generate even sweeter compounds, such as the approved food additive neotame, which is 7000–13000 times sweeter than sucrose31. In this study, N-butyl-L-aspartic acid (3f), which is the precursor to neotame analog, was synthesized on a kilogram scale using whole cells fermented from merely 2 L medium with excellent conversion (> 97%), isolated yield (92%, 1.4 kg), and stereoselectivity (> 99% e.e.) (Fig. 3D), demonstrating the great potential of the redesigned AspBs to offer alternative synthetic options for the industrial preparation of valuable ncAA products.
One-pot chemoenzymatic synthesis of β-lactam compounds.
The significantly broader substrate scope of the redesigned C-N lyases has also raised the possibility of building entirely new synthetic pathways for valuable precursors to pharmaceuticals. By harnessing the elegance of biocatalysis and the robustness of chemical catalysis, efficient routes toward the β-lactam heterocycle, one of the most acclaimed pharmacophoric moieties32, from simple starting materials were examined. With the enzymatically prepared ncAAs in hand, we subsequently performed the cyclization reaction in the same pot without purification, accomplishing the full conversion for the second cyclization step. The substrate cyclopropylamine (j), which could be efficiently converted by BA15 with 99% conversion, was chosen for our initial investigation. The one-pot chemoenzymatically prepared β-lactam product 1jc was isolated with moderate overall yield (63%) and excellent optical purity (e.e. > 99%) and without racemization of the potentially sensitive Cβ stereogenic center (Fig. 4A). To further demonstrate the synthetic usefulness of this one-pot synthetic strategy, 1 g, 1i, 1 k, 2 h, 2i, and 2 k, which were well accepted substrates of the redesigned enzymes, were chosen and provided good overall isolated yields (46–71%). The results demonstrated a simplified practical procedure toward optically pure β-lactam heterocycles through a one-pot chemoenzymatic synthesis route.
It is noteworthy that alkenes and alkynes are highly versatile synthetic handles suitable for elaboration into a wide variety of useful functional groups. The modification of the alkyne or alkene tag in β-lactam heterocycles via well-established click chemistry allows the introduction of bulky reporter groups (e.g., rhodamine). Therefore, the corresponding probes are useful tools to study enzyme activity, function, and assembly33. To our delight, the use of 2ic as the alkyne donor was feasible, and the corresponding azole product was obtained in 3 h as ascertained by ESI-MS (Fig. 4B). The successful attempt to synthesize chemoenzymatic β-lactam heterocycles via click chemistry may further provide access to tailor-made enzyme inhibitors and provide potential molecular probes to unravel the activity and function of proteins.