In recent years, reports of ranavirus epizootics have increased with viruses such as the European North Atlantic ranavirus, emerging as a novel species 22. It has also been reported that outbreaks of FV3-like ranavirus can result in high mortality for animals both in the wild and in captivity 2. FV3-like ranavirus is the only member of the Iridoviridae reported in turtles as its presence is enhanced by anthropogenic activities such as importing or exporting infected animals as pets or for food, and agricultural activities 2. The FV3-like ON turtle/2018 ranavirus sequenced in this study is the first confirmed ranavirus-induced mortality in a reptile (snapping turtle) in Canada 23 and our analysis offers new insight into the genome of an FV3-like virus derived from a dead reptile host.
The FV3-like ON turtle/2018 genome was compared to the published wt-FV3 genome, along with previously identified FV3-like genomes and other ranavirus genome sequences. Phylogenetic analysis placed the FV3-like ON turtle/2018 strain in the FV3-like clade, consistent with its high nucleotide sequence identity to other FV3-like viral strains. The FV3-like ON turtle/2018 strain showed the highest nucleotide identity (99.71%) to the genome of the wt-FV3 and an FV3-like strain detected in Alberta, Canada (S. Table 1). Based on the genome structure and organization, the FV3-like ON turtle/2018 genome possesses genetic features that are present in the wt-FV3 genome including all of the core Iridoviridae and FV3-like genes. Nine ORFs (31R, 34R, 41R, 45L, 47L, 49L, 50L, 51R and 82R) were identified to be truncated in the FV3-like ON turtle/2018 genome compared to the wt-FV3 and other reported FV3-like genomes. Three of the nine truncated ORFs were Iridoviridae core ORFs (31R (a secretory protein), 34R (Human parainfluenza virus 1 L protein, transmembrane domain), and 82R (secretory protein)) suggesting these genes may be critical for viral replication and transmission. Many viruses utilize secretory pathways to facilitate viral replication 24, while transmembrane domains may play a role in the co-localization of viruses to the endoplasmic reticulum 24,25. Previous work identified truncations in ORFs of newly characterized FV3-like genomes in two (34R and 41R) of the nine ORFs in question in the Ran-Bra-01 strain, although the significance of these identified truncations remains unknown 25. Thus future studies that focus on the functional analysis of ranavirus and FV3-like core genes are essential to elucidate the specific roles and phenotypic consequences of these truncated ORFs. Our findings demonstrate and identify genetic variations present between closely related FV3-like strains in coding regions 24. Altogether, the genomic differences identified in the FV3-like ON turtle/2018 genome compared to the wt-FV3 genome may contribute to, or be a result of the adaptation of the FV3-like ON turtle/2018 strain to infecting a novel host-turtle.
The present study is the first to investigate the nucleotide comparison of all ORFs and relative synonymous codon usage analysis of FV3-like strains. Results of the codon usage analysis revealed that the FV3-like turtle ON/2018 shares a similar relative synonymous codon usage to the wt-FV3, the Z994 FV3-like strain, an ATV strain and an EHNC strain. Also, the nucleotide composition analysis showed that the FV3-like genomes have a higher G/C-ending codon compared to A/T–ending codons. From these analyses, it can be concluded that the G/C-ending codons may be the preferred codons over the A/T-ending codons in the five ranavirus genomes analyzed from different hosts representing different taxonomic classes. A study by Tian et al. investigated codon usage bias of the major capsid protein-coding genes of five groups of ranavirus and reported that amphibian-like ranaviruses prefer C- and G- ending codons (Tian et al., 2020). In addition, the nucleotide composition of the FV3-like turtle ON/2018 genome is similar to other FV3-like strains. These findings support the hypothesis by McKenzie et al., 23 that the FV3-like ON turtle/2018 ranavirus likely emerged in snapping turtles from amphibians sharing the same environment 10,26, since results of this study show that whole-genome sequence comparison and codon usage in this reptile derived strain was similar to that of the amphibian derived strains. Interclass transmission of ranaviruses was demonstrated in a controlled laboratory setting 6 in a study by Brenes et al, using FV3-like ranavirus infected gray tree frog larvae, mosquito fish and read-eared slider. It was shown that the FV3-like exposed gray tree frog larvae were capable of transmitting ranavirus to unexposed larvae and turtles. Their findings support the hypothesis that interclass transmission may occur in wild populations for FV3-like ranaviruses 6.
Previous studies have shown that some ranavirus species evolve from different localities through recombination 17,27. Recombination events in viruses are also an important mechanism involved in viral-host adaptation to new environments 28. These events commonly occur in ranaviruses and our analysis of the FV3-like ON turtle/2018 genome further supports these findings. Our analysis revealed four potential recombination events in the newly isolated FV3-like ON turtle/2018 strain when compared to FV3-like strains and these events were located in breakpoints that contain multiple core ORFs. Potential major parental FV3-like strains were identified as the wt-FV3 virus from the United States for three of the four recombination events. The potential parental lineage of the fourth recombination event was identified as either the Ran-Bra-01 - Brazil strain, the Op/2015 strain detected in the Netherlands (imported from Nicaragua), or the FV3-like Z897 strain from NWT, Canada. This suggests that the FV3-like ON turtle/2018 strain may be a mosaic derived from recombination events involving ranaviruses introduced by anthropogenic factors such as the global commercial exotic pet trade. Investigations of recombination events, such as these, are important since recombinant strains may alter the phenotype and lead to changes in pathogenicity and/or the hosts range. For example, the recombinant CMTV-like RCV-Z2 bullfrog isolate, an FV3 x CMTV recombinant ranavirus that was more pathogenic than wt-FV3 27. Furthermore, investigating recombination events has the potential to study the anthropogenic factors driving the evolution of viruses.
Ranavirus infections have been identified in outbreaks of captive and free-ranging eastern box turtles and so genomic comparison was performed with the only available whole-genome sequence of a common box turtle infecting ranavirus, Terrapene carolina carolina ranavirus (TCCR). The TCCR, detected in common box turtles in the United States, has been sequenced and reported to be most closely related to an FV3-like strains 10,29. However, FV3-like turtle ON/2018 is a distinct strain sharing only 99.17% genome-wide nucleotide identity with TCCR and TCCR was not identified as a potential parental strain in any of the significant recombination events. The mechanisms and significance of changes resulting from recombination events remain unknown; however, genetic recombination of viruses has been reported to influence the formation of novel chimeric genomes that drive the establishment of viral diversity, variation and could lead to the creation of novel viruses 30. Indeed, a highly invasive chimeric ranavirus identified in the United States, as a result of multiple recombination events, was shown to decimate tadpole populations rapidly as compared to non-chimeric ranaviruses 30. Therefore, additional recombination analysis of FV3-like ranavirus genomes isolated from new reptile or non-amphibian hosts may shed light on the emergence and spread of novel viral strains in different cold-blooded vertebrates.
The results presented here reinforce the need for characterization and comparison of viral strains obtained from similar or different hosts using WGS, and that strain identification, based on a single or a few genes, is insufficient. Diagnostic PCR tests that target the major capsid protein can confirm the presence or absence of the targeted gene, but offer little information for characterizing novel viral strains, such as the gene structure and genomic arrangement of the virus being studied. This study provides the first hybrid de novo whole-genome assembly of an FV3-like genome generated using both long and short-read sequencing technologies; most of the previously characterized FV3-like genomes were assembled using short reads generated using Illumina sequencers, or direct sequencing of PCR products. By using a combination of Illumina short-read and Nanopore long-read sequencing, we aimed to improve the genome completeness and accuracy of the FV3-like ON turtle/2018 assembly 31. Also, using both sequencing platforms has allowed us to improve the assembly of the FV3-like ON turtle/2018 genome and to study the presence of potential recombination events and codon usage bias and function of the FV3-like strain. The long read data also helped resolve repetitive sequences present in the Iridoviridae genome that have been reported to function as regulatory sequences 30. It is expected that the high-quality FV3-like ON turtle/2018 genome obtained in this study will serve as a reference sequence resource for future turtle/reptile-derived FV3-like ranaviruses.