Charctersitsics of the Study Participants
Characteristics of Interviewed Health Care Workers
A total of 18 (8 males, 10 females) out of 21 HCWs who routinely diagnosed and treated PWE in Mwanza region were enrolled in this study. Majority, 8 (44.4%) of them were nurses (table 1). Among eight nurses who managed PWE, 3 (37.5%) were trained in mental health and the the rest were general nurses. There were no epilepsy specialists (neurologists) in the region. There was only one specialist in other specialities (Psychiatrist) who regularly managed PWE (table 1).
Table 1: Inteviwed Health Care Workers who diagnosed and treated PWE
Cadre
|
Number
|
Percentage
|
Psychiatrist
|
1
|
5.6
|
General Medical Officers
|
5
|
27.8
|
Clinical Officers
|
4
|
22.2
|
Nurses
|
8
|
44.4
|
Total
|
18
|
100
|
Characteristics of PWE Participants
A total of 218 PWE with mean age of 29.0 ± 13.7 years were enrolled in this study. Among them, 106 (486%) were males and 112 (51.4%) were females. Majority of them were recruited from BMC (table 2).
Table 2: Distribution of PWE who participated in the Study by centre
Hospital
|
Number
|
Percentage
|
Magu
|
40
|
18.3
|
Ukerewe
|
40
|
18.3
|
Sengerema
|
50
|
22.9
|
Kwimba
|
32
|
14.7
|
BMC
|
56
|
25.7
|
Total
|
218
|
100.0
|
Hospital Units for Managing People with Epilepsy
In all five hospitals studied, there were no special units for managing PWE. In 4/5 hospitals PWE were treated in psychiatric or mental health clinics while in the remaining one hospital, they were managed in general outpatient clinic. Electroencephalogram (EEG), computed tomograph (CT) scan and AED level monitoring facilities were available only in one centre (consultant referral hospital) out of the five. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) machine was not available in all five hospitals. Electrocardiogram (ECG) machines were available in the consultant referral hospital and one distric hospital while echocardiogram was found only in the consultant referall hospital. Facilities for measuring hematological profile, serum electrolytes and liver functions were available in all five hospitals.
Documentation of Epilepsy Cases
In all five centres, epilepsy cases were documented without having their seizures classified.
Investigations and Treatment of Epilepsy
Only 2/18 (11.1%) HCWs, all from consultant hospital reported that, they sometimes used investigations to confirm epilepsy diagnosis or explore its causes. The rest of HCWs had nerver ordered investigation in the course of diagnosis of epilepsy. When 218 patients or their caretakers were asked about the investigations, which were done to them, only 11 (5.0 %), 3 (1.4%), 1 (0.5%) had EEG, CT scan and MRI respectively done. These investigations were not necessarily being done in the five selected hospitals but could be in other diagnostic centres within the region or in other regions. None of the patient had cardiac investigations (ECG or Echocardiograph) done to exclude cardiac syncope or fainting from epileptic seizures. No follow-up investigations (full blood count, liver enzymes, serum electrolytes or AEDs level measurements) were done in any of the 218 participant patients.
Most of HCWs, 10 /18 (55.6%) reported that counseling was given to newly diagnosed PWE. However, PWE or their caretakers revealed that counseling information regarding the use of AEDs was largely inadequate. One sixty (73.4%) of patients or caretakers reported that detailed discussion about what does epilepsy mean, how is it acquired and how can it be treated was given to them. One sixty seven (76.6%) PWE were told the importance of using AEDs and 75 (34.4%) were informed about the available AEDs to use and their costs. However, only 34 (15.6%) patients were told about the AEDs side effects. Majority of patients, 140 (64.2%) were told to avoid alcohol use but only 7 (3.2%) of them were told about the drugs to avoid while using AEDs.
Among 218 patients who were managed as PWE, three of them did not have symptoms or history suggestive of epilepsy. One of them had symptoms of psychiatric disoder with neither history of seizures nor loss of consciousness. Two had history of single episode of febrile convulsions during their first years of life but continued to receive phenobarbital (PB) for more than 10 years.
Phenytoin (PHT) and PB were mostly used AEDs by PWE in Mwanza region. In Magu district hospital, 38/40 patients used either PHT or PB or the two drugs together; one patient used carbamazepine (CBZ) and one used PHT and CBZ. In Kwimba district hospital, all patients used PB, with two each using either PHT or CBZ in addition to PB. In Sengerema district hospital, 41/50 patients used PHT and PB together, 6/50 used PB alone, 2/50 used PHT and CBZ and 1/50 was not using any drug. The AEDs used by 31/32 patients treated in Ukerewe district hospital were PHT, PB and CBZ either as monotherapy or in combination. One out of 32 patients used Keppra in combination with PB. Fifty six patients treated at BMC used PHT, PB, CBZ or valproic acid (VPA) either as monotherapy or combination of two drugs.
The AEDs prescriptions were mainly dictated by drug availability and affordability to patients, rather than seizure types and drug tolerability to patients (table 3). There was lack of consistence in type of drugs given to patients in the four district hospitals. The drug given was dictated by its availability in hospital during a hospital visit. Sometimes, there was switching between PHT and PB.
Table 3: Choice of AEDs for Prescription
Reason for Prescription
|
Number of practitionners (n=18)
|
Percentage of prcatitionners
|
Affordability to patients
|
14
|
77.8
|
Availability of drug in the hospital or market
|
18
|
100.0
|
AED side effects
|
7
|
38.9
|
Seizure type
|
3
|
16.7
|
Other reasons
|
4
|
22.2
|
* Respondents gave multiple reasons
Four patients (1.8%) were found to have used the drugs that are normally contraindicated to use with AEDs.
Twentyseven out of 218 (12.4%) and 109/218 (50.0%) patients were given subtherapeutic and sub-optimal therapeutic doses respectively (table 4). Among the patients who were given subtherapeutic and sub-optimal therapeutic doses, 15 (55.6%) and 57 (52.3%) respectively had one or more seizure in the past 30 days.
Table 4. Dosages of AEDs used by PWE treated in Mwanza
Dosage of AEDs used
|
Frequency (and percentage)
|
Magu
|
Kwimba
|
Sengerema
|
Ukerewe
|
BMC
|
Total
|
Subtherapeutic
|
6
|
1
|
1
|
16
|
3
|
27
|
Suboptimal therapeutic
|
33
|
1
|
32
|
9
|
34
|
109
|
Optimal therapeutic
|
|
36
|
3
|
6
|
16
|
61
|
Total
|
39
|
38
|
36
|
31
|
53
|
197
|
*In 21patients, doses were not documented or patients were not on medication
Ten out of 18 (55.6%) prescribers did not stop AEDs medication to their patients despite of long period of seizure free and the rest, stopped medication after varying periods (1–5 years) of seizure free.