This study investigated the prevalence of insomnia symptoms in clinically stable older psychiatric patients and their impact on QOL during the COVID-19 outbreak in China. Over half (57.1%, 95%CI: 53.9%-60.2%) of the patients suffered from insomnia symptoms, which is higher than the corresponding figures reported in other populations using the same measure and cutoff value during the COVID-19 outbreak, such as frontline clinicians (28.75%-38.4%) (36–38), inpatients with COVID-19 (42.8%) (14), breast cancer patients (36.2%) (39), and the general population (28.5%) (40). In addition, the prevalence of insomnia symptoms in this study was also much higher than the figures in both the general population (15.0%, 95%CI: 12.1%-18.5%) (41) and older psychiatric patients (27.0%, 95%CI: 24.5%-29.4%) (42) in China before the COVID-19 outbreak, although measures on insomnia symptoms were different.
The reasons for frequent insomnia symptoms in older psychiatric patients are complex. Psychiatric disorders and insomnia symptoms often co-exist, because sleep rhythm often changes in many psychiatric disorders as well as with the use of psychotropic medications (43, 44). Besides, age is a risk factor for insomnia (45). In older adults, sleep and circadian rhythm changes occur along with the physiologic changes, which presents as gradually decreased sleep efficiency and total sleep time. Unrealistic expectations about sleep duration and quality could elevate the risk of insomnia (46). Moreover, increased prevalence of medical problems (e.g., nocturia and physical disability) (47) and treatments (e.g., beta-blockers, glucocorticoids, and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs) (46) could contribute to the occurrence of insomnia. Aging women including those with psychiatric disorders are more likely to suffer from insomnia symptoms (44, 50) than men. However, no gender difference was found in the current study. This discrepancy between the current and previous studies may be due to the increased prevalence of insomnia symptoms in both genders during the COVID-19 outbreak, which may offset the gender difference found earlier.
The COVID-19 outbreak could further trigger insomnia symptoms and related problems in older psychiatric patients for a number of reasons. First, more severe consequences and higher mortality rates in older adults with COVID-19 could spread fear and mental distress. Second, mass quarantine measures lead to loneliness, fatigue, and daytime sleepiness (48, 49) and thus affect sleep and circadian rhythm. Third, older psychiatric patients have frequent comorbid chronic medical conditions and require long-term medication treatment. Difficulties in attending hospitals during the COVID-19 outbreak further aggravate patients’ distress about discontinuation of treatment contributing to the development of insomnia symptoms.
As expected, patients with insomnia symptoms reported more severe depressive symptoms in this study. The association between insomnia symptoms and depressive disorders is bidirectional. On one hand, insomnia symptoms are a risk factor of depressive disorders (50, 51); on the other hand, depressive disorders increase the likelihood of insomnia symptoms (52). In meta-analyses insomnia symptoms significantly predicted the onset of depressive episodes (51, 53, 54) with an overall odds ratio (OR) of up to 2.83 (95%CI: 1.55–5.17) (51). This could be partly explained by the impairment of emotional processing caused by insomnia, which could lead to depressive symptoms (55). Furthermore, the association between insomnia and depressive symptoms might be related to common pathomechanisms, e.g., similar alterations of arousal states (56–58) and level of inflammatory markers (59). In this study, patients with other psychiatric diagnoses, mainly schizophrenia and organic mental disorders, were more likely to suffer from insomnia symptoms than those with MDD. The diagnostic heterogeneity makes it difficult to interpret the reasons for the unexpectedly significant group difference. Head-to-head comparative studies between different psychiatric diagnoses are warranted to replicate or refute this finding.
Patients with insomnia symptoms had a lower overall QOL than those without, which is consistent with previous findings (60, 61). According to the distress/protection QOL model (62), QOL is determined by the interaction between protective (e.g., good social support and economic status) and distressing factors (e.g., poor health). Insomnia symptoms are associated with impaired daytime functioning (63), deficits of attention, working memory, and executive function (64), poor physical health (18), and psychiatric symptoms (65), all of which could lower QOL.
The strengths of this study include the multicenter study-design and the large sample size, which increase the overall representativeness of the study sample. However, several methodological limitations need to be addressed. First, the study only included clinically stable patients, which limits the generalizability of the findings to patients in different illness stage. Second, due to logistical reasons during the COVID-19 outbreak, clinical stability was judged by the treating psychiatrists, rather assessed by the aid of standardized rating instruments. Third, the causal relationships between demographic and clinical characteristics and insomnia symptoms could not be examined due to the cross-sectional study design. Fourth, factors potentially associated with of insomnia symptoms (e.g., social support and economic status) were not examined in this study.