EETS continues to improve owing to recent advances in equipment, hemostatic reagents, and closure techniques; the incidence of CSF leakage has been reduced to a range from 0.5 to 12% following EETS.1,7−9 However, there are still some factors unrelated to surgical skills that could impact the rates of intra- and postoperative CSF leakage; those factors have been poorly defined, and our data suggest that certain factors can predict a greater likelihood of CSF leakages both in the intra- and postoperative periods of EETS.
In studies of CSF leakage in pituitary adenomas after transnasal surgery, most of the researchers found that CSF leakage occurred in most patients with an intraoperative CSF leakage;3,4,10 thus, intraoperative CSF leakage seems to be an important risk factor for postoperative CSF leakage. Similarly, this conclusion was also confirmed in our study. Nine patients had a postoperative CSF leakage, and seven of them had an intraoperative CSF leakage; the final multivariate regression analysis showed intraoperative CSF leakage as an independent risk factor for postoperative CSF leakage (OR, 7.707; P = 0.022).
Based on the results above, we can see that it is important to prevent intraoperative CSF leakage to reduce the rate of postoperative CSF leakage; understanding the risk factors of intraoperative CSF leakage is beneficial in its management and prevention of postoperative CSF leakage. It is obvious that all the factors that can induce diaphragma sellae rupture can lead to a CSF leakage; thus, the factors impacting the rupture of the diaphragm sellae can also lead to intraoperative CSF leakages. In our reports, we observed the significant difference in the tumor size between those who had an intraoperative CSF rhinorrhea and those who did not (16.84 ± 6.16 vs 26.20 ± 7.83; P < 0.001). Zhou et al.4 also reported a high incidence of intraoperative CSF leakage following a large size pituitary adenoma resection; the final multi-factor regression analysis demonstrated that it was an independent risk factor for intraoperative CSF rhinorrhea. The mechanism of the tumor size being a risk factor of CSF leakage in surgery may be due to suprasellar extension in large size tumor,which can leading to a rather thin diaphragm sellae. Therefore, we think a gentle manipulation is necessary for large pituitary adenomas to avoid the rapture of a rather thin diaphragm sellae in surgery. At the same time, we can also remove the tumor in the following order: rear, two sides, and front to avoid dropping the diaphragma sellae too early and too fast, which may lead to its rupture and consequently CSF leakage.
Our results revealed that CRD had increased the risk of postoperative CSF leakage (OR, 57.5; P < 0.01). To our knowledge, this has never been reported in the literature until now. This result may be related to the increased intracranial pressure during the acute onset of CRD. The increased intrathoracic pressure leading to a decreased blood flow of the jugular vein resulting in an increased intracranial pressure may cause herniation of the repaired material from the sellar base and CSF leakage. Two other studies11,12 had proven the mechanism of an increased intracranial pressure playing an important role in the occurrence of postoperative CSF leakage or a spontaneous CSF leakage. Hanba et al.12 discovered that patients with asthma are more likely to have CSF leakage than patients without asthma after transnasal surgery; further, the rate of postoperative CSF leakage in these two groups was 4.7% and 2.7%, respectively. Fleischman et al.11 found that patients with obstructive sleep apnea are more likely to develop a spontaneous CSF leakage.
Previous studies3,13 have already reported that BMI was a risk factor for postoperative CSF leakage following EETS, however, incidence of CSF leakage did not correlate with BMI in our series. Dlouhy et al.13 and Karnezis et al.3 both indicated that BMI was a risk factor for postoperative CSF leakage. However, the average BMI of the CSF leakage group compared with that of the non-CSF leakage group in these two studies was 33.1:30.3 kg/m2 and 39.2:32.9 kg/m2, respectively; both of their patients’ average BMI was greater than 30 kg/m2. In our study, the average BMI was ~ 21.80:21.66 kg/m2, which was lower than those in the previous studies. We think it is possible that the average BMI in our patients was not elevated enough to lead to a spontaneous increase in the intracranial pressure, which can result in postoperative CSF rhinorrhea.
Some studies have suggested that a VNFP can reduce the incidence of postoperative CSF leakage to less than 6%.14–16 Currently, using vascularized mucosal flaps has become a recognized method for sellar base reconstruction. Obviously, the incidence of postoperative CSF leakage in our patients significantly reduced by the use of VNFP and abdominal fascial graft. The blood supply of the VNFPs was mainly derived from the septal artery, which is rich in blood flow; thus, the survival rate was higher than those in any other non-vascular mucosal flaps.14 El-sayed et al.14 also pointed out that the atrophy of the mucous with a VNFP was smaller than that with a non-vascular mucosa flap, which was not enough to detach the mucosal flap from the sellar base.
Whether the use of lumbar subarachnoid drains reduces the rates of postoperative CSF rhinorrhea remains controversial.17,18 Some researchers noted that the use of intraoperative lumbar subarachnoid drain did not significantly reduce the postoperative CSF leakage rate.19,18 However, Stokken et al.20 indicated that in patients with a high-flow intraoperative CSF leakage, the use of a lumbar subarachnoid drain can immediately reduce the risk for postoperative CSF leakage. Conversely, our study found that the use of such did not significantly reduce the risk of postoperative CSF leakage. Using a lumbar subarachnoid drain can also easily lead to intracranial infection18 and prolonged hospitalization;19 thus, we think careful consideration in using a lumbar subarachnoid drain intraoperatively to prevent postoperative CSF leakage is necessary.